Click to return to the first page


Click to return to previous page

The Reels

As best I can figure out, and I bet I’m right:


Reel 1

End of Reel 1

Reel 2

End of Reel 2

Reel 3

End of Reel 3

Reel 4

End of Reel 4

Reel 5

End of Reel 5

Reel 6

End of Reel 6

Reel 7

End of Reel 7

Reel 8

End of Reel 8
When you go through the publicity materials and the trade publications of 1926/1927, you will see that The General was everywhere announced as 7,500'. That was wrong. I do not know why nobody corrected that error. Even in modern sources, which should know better, the erroneous length of 7,500' still appears everywhere. The complete film, at 90'/min. (24fps), runs 1:18:42, and that comes to 7,083', but there are 22 frames (1'4½") missing from the negative at 0:47:19 (as Johnnie stops the locomotive just before he breaks the telegraph wires), apparently damaged and removed many moons ago. So, let’s add one foot to 7,083' to get 7,084'. The total, if measured on a film-measuring machine, could prove to be maybe a foot shorter or maybe a foot longer, depending on variables, but 7,084' is a good, reliable number, almost exactly the correct number.


The jump in the action is a result of damage, which led to 22 frames
lost from the OCN (Original Camera Negative).
Interestingly, these frames are also missing from the 1979 Rohauer edition.


Above is a little something I just found on YouTube, Charlie Tarbox’s copy of a copy of a copy of the Harvard/MoMA print. In early 1927, when United Artists donated The General to Harvard, there had not yet been any damage to the original, and so there is no gap in the action.

Here we have the Jay Ward reissue that was ready prior to April 1970. The previous shot is edited out. The shot of Johnnie stopping his train is shortened and picks up immediately after the 22-frame gap in the negative. Jay Ward’s edition was from a fine-grain that MGM had purchased from UA in 1947 or 1948. So now we know that the 22 frames went missing from UA’s camera negative no later than 1948.

Here we have Paul Killiam’s edition of July 1970, semi-reconstituted from cans of trims and reassembled out of sequence. Since there was a 22-frame gap in his source material, a gap that would have revealed that he had, without permission, copied the MGM fine-grain, Paul deleted the beginning of this shot so that nobody would see a jump in the action.


The Original Music Cues

When Art Pierce of the Capitol Theatre in Rome (NY, not Italy) told me he had the original cue sheets for The General, I just died. When I got better, I asked for photocopies, and he said “Sure!” I was expecting sheerest brilliance, but what greeted my eyes was something else altogether. Buster was not in charge of the music, I am certain. He simply trusted orchestra conductors and organists and so forth to do their jobs.

If you do not see the document embedded below, please use a different browser or open the file here.




What do we make of this? First, James C. Bradford tossed together this set of cues without any finesse. It is obvious that he cared nothing for the movie. It is obvious also that he was not a creative thinker. He knew a few thousand tunes and he just grabbed whatever the tired old formula suggested: hurry music, storm music, dixie music, military music, and so forth, with not a thought to mood or purpose or theme or context. Few of the old standards and contemporary pop tunes that he recommended fit the film. Most of the cues flatly contradicted the film. Second, further to demonstrate the hastiness with which these cues were assembled, we can examine the lengths of each cue, for many of those lengths do not match the film, no matter what speed is used in the projection. We can suppose that a handful of cinemas followed these cues, but conductors at deluxe houses would have assembled their own scores, and cinemas with pit bands, organs, or pianos, would have improvised. I see that Dennis James disagrees with me: Sandra Barrera, “Buster Keaton’s ‘The General’ with Original Score to Be Performed Live at CSUN’s VPACLos Ángeles Daily News, 24 March 2017.

Ah. Take a look at the Library of Congress’s website. It posts a scan of this four-page cue sheet from the “Jack Butterworth collection of silent film cues 1917.–1929,” This is from an unidentified cinema that began its booking on Friday, 30 September 1927. My guess is that an organist accompanied, and it seems that this organist did not have all these pieces in inventory, or, more likely, it seems that the organist did not know all of Bradford’s suggested cues by heart. So, this organist revised some of the cues. Fascinating, yes?

By no means am I an expert on this topic, and I shall gladly defer to those who have studied cue sheets for silent films. Nonetheless, I can make a tentative guess. If Bradford’s work is in any way representative of cue sheets, then cue sheets were haphazard, just random bits commonly in the repertoire of cinemas’ music libraries, tunes that the musicians knew almost by heart and that could easily be used as a stopgap measure. There was probably no expectation that any musicians would even look at these cue sheets unless they were beset by emergencies and thus unable to cobble together their own scores.

Who is this James C. Bradford, anyway? Well, it turns out that he was not a hack after all. I bet he was under enormous pressure and resorted to hack techniques in order to get his work done. Here is his capsule bio from IMDb:

Born: June 13, 1885 in Rochester, New York, USA
Died: May 11, 1941 in Neponsit, New York, USA

Composer, author, pianist, teacher and conductor, educated in New York public schools. He studied with Tali Esen Morgan, and led his own orchestra, while also teaching piano in Asbury Park, New York. Joining ASCAP in 1928, his song compositions include “Triestesse,” “Gigue,” “Amour Discret,” “Valse Frivole,” “Magic Love,” “The Fearless Suitor,” “Marching Song of the Foreign Legion,” “Chanson Algerian,” “The Moorings,” and “Sarabande,”


Many moons ago, I grabbed my 1989 Kino “Collector’s Edition” VHS copy of the movie, transferred at 90'/min, with an organ score by Gaylord Carter, and I jotted down the counter times to check them against the cue sheets’ times. My results are below. As you will see, the timings are just ballpark figures, typed up in a rush, never double-checked. I think it was Rod Sauer who explained to me, in an email message many moons ago, that the timings in cue sheets are not to be taken literally. The cue sheets offer a basic guide for the sort of music suggested for each scene, not for the length of the scenes or the speed of projection.

In years past, I was helpless to hear the music cited, but the world has changed in many ways of late. Most of these tunes can now be heard online, and of the ones that are not available, some of the printed music can be downloaded. A few I cannot locate anywhere online, though several are available for order at sometimes hefty prices. I found most of the cues, though. Click on the links. I think you will agree that most of these pieces have no business accompanying The General.

  Cue Tune VCR Counter Stated Length Actual Length 90'/min
1 At screening Dixie Queen March, 1900, Ellis L. Brooks 0:00:00 ½ 0:49
2 The Western and Atlantic Flyer Alabamy Bound, 1924, m. Ray Henderson, l. Buddy DeSylva and Bud Green 0:00:49 1 1:08
3 There were two loves I’ve Been Working on the Railroad, 1894, anonymous 0:01:57 1 1:15
4 Enters house The Parlor Is a Pleasant Place, 1920, Frank Crumit 0:03:12 ½ 0:56
5 Fort Sumpter [sic] has been fired upon Light Cavalry Overture, 1866, Franz von Suppé 0:04:16 1 ¼ 1:29
6 Recruiting station Fantasie Dixie, Emil Mollenhauer 0:05:50 3 ¼ 3:40
7 Johnny back at locomotive Dear Old Southland, 1921; m. Turner Layton; l. Henry Creamer 0:09:30 1 ¾ 1:55
8 A year later My Own United States, 1902, Julian Edwards 0:11:25 1 ½ 1:41
9 Insert—Marietta Maryland, My Maryland, 1861, after Melchior Franck (not Beyer) 0:13:06 ¾ 0:44
10 Train pulls out The Mill, 1909, Adolf Jensen 0:13:50 ¾ 0:15
11 Passengers alight from train Dramatic Tension, 1926, Charles Ancliffe 0:14:05 ½ 0:49
12 Yankees hop train—escape Galop des Gendarmes, 1897, Marius Cairanne 0:14:54 2 ½ 3:06
13 Those men stole my General Comedy Galop, Philipp Fahrbach the Younger (1843–1894) 0:18:00 3 ½ 3:56
14 Loads cannon again Sawdust and Spangles, 1921, Richard E Hildreth 0:21:56 3 4:34
15 Johnny bounces ties from track The Steeplechase, 1924, Irénée Marius Bergé 0:26:30 2 ¼ 2:50
16 The Southern army Old Folks at Home (Paraphrase), William P. Kretschmer 0:29:20 1 1:12
17 General Parker’s victorious army Memories of the War 1861–1863, 1908, Louis-Philippe Laurendeau 0:30:32 1 ¾ 2:13
18 Johnny leaves locomotive Short Storm Scene, Fred Hoff 0:32:45 1 0:54
19 Johnny sneaks into house Marche Burlesque, 1903, Érnest Gillet 0:33:39 2 3:30
20 Officers leave train [sic] Ghost Scene, 1925, Walter Broy 0:37:09 3 ½ 4:43
21 It was so brave of you Pick Me Up and Lay Me Down [in Dear Old Dixieland], 1922, Bert Kalmar and Harry Ruby 0:41:52 ½ 0:28
22 After a nice quiet, refreshing Humpty Dumpty’s Funeral March, 1885, Frederick Brandeis 0:42:20 ½ 0:45
23 Activity at railroad 1863 Medley, 1904, E.C. Calvin 0:43:05 2 ¼ 2:08
24 Johnny starts walking with bag Marche Burlesque, 1903, Érnest Gillet 0:45:13 ½ 0:21
25 Johnny socks officer Cosmopolite [Galop], 1898, Albert Labbé 0:45:34 2 ¾ 4:28
26 We must pick up more wood Thrills [Scherzo], 1925, Geo. H. Sanders 0:49:58 1 ¼ 1:44
27 Engine approaching The Plunger [Galop], 1917, Thomas Stephen Allen 0:51:42 2 ½ 3:10
28 Get away from water tower Skaters’ Galop, Philipp Fahrbach the Younger (1843–1894) 0:54:52 2 ¾ 2:15
29 Pulls switch Military Galop, 1925, Ch. Barthman 0:58:07 2 ¼ 3:12
30 The Northern division Around the Campfire, 1920, Julius S. Seredy 1:01:19 ½ 0:31
31 Pours kerosene oil on logs Military Scene, 1918, William Christopher O’Hare 1:01:50 1 ½ 1:59
32 Train pulls into station Military Tactics, 1917, George “Rosey” Rosenberg 1:03:49 ¾ 1:13
33 Southern commander at head of troop American Fantasie, 1918, Victor Herbert 1.05:02 1 1:32
34 Northern soldiers at switch Military Tactics, 1917, George “Rosey” Rosenberg 1:06:34 2 ¼ 2:30
35 Battle starts Storm, Strife or Tempest, Charles Ancliffe 1:09:04 3 ¼ 4:13
36 Heroes of the day Dixie (from “An American Battle Scene”), 1898, Theo. Moses-Tobani 1:13:17 ¾ 1:00
37 Johnny sees officer on floor of engine Army of the Gray (from “An American Battle Scene”), 1898, Theo. Moses-Tobani 1:14:17 1 ¼ 1:30
38 Is that your uniform Miracle of Love, 1917, McKee Trio 1:15:47 ½ 0:58
39 He puts on new uniform coat Willie, We Have Missed You (from “Gems of Stephen Foster” compiled by Theo. Moses Tobani), 1862 1:16:45 ¾ 0:53
40 Sits on engine Alabamy Bound, 1924, m. Ray Henderson, l. Buddy DeSylva and Bud Green 1:17:38 ¾ 1:02
  THE END   1:18:40    
      TOTAL   1:18:40 61 ¾ 78:40


Now let us take a look at what Daniel Moews pronounced Maze wrote in his book, Keaton: The Silent Features Close Up (Berkeley, Los Ángeles, London: University of California Press, 1977), pp. 324–326:

Though the musical accompaniment... would probably still work..., the drawback... is that too many of the musical selections are too popular. The sheets are the mass-produced compilations of skillful hacks, assembling pieces that an average musician could quickly handle; and since the selections are often so well-known, they insistently call attention to themselves, distracting attention from the film.... The original cue sheets, while a purist might enjoy using them, have too many limitations to ever become again the standard accompaniment for the films....

With The General in 1926, the cue sheet states the running times only for individual themes, which add up to a total of 61¾ minutes. Other sources, however, like the American Film Institute Catalog, generally give 7,500 feet as the film’s length, and assuming that this closely corresponds to its length at the time of its first release, one can compute an astonishing projection speed of 32.3 frames per second. That is one-third faster than sound projection speed today, a fact that might help explain the surprisingly unenthusiastic critical reception the film first received. A contemporary viewing of it might have been a painful exercise in keeping up with the super-fast motion of a mechanical dervish, allowing no time or opportunity to enjoy anything but the most obvious and protracted of the rapidly passing gags.

For the present, then, twenty-four frames per second seems right. That works well and is closest to the original speeds. On the other hand, there is so much visual detail packed into the Keaton films, so many momentary and often subsidiary comic touches, that a naive audience unaccustomed to the attentiveness required by the films might feel more at ease, might even enjoy them more, if they were shown at the slower present-day silent speed. I can foresee the rise of purists, too, who will insist on watching The General at exactly 32.3 frames per second, no more, no less.


That passage, in an otherwise well-informed and well-reasoned book, is only to be expected. That was the state of knowledge in the late 1970’s, and it was a very poor state of knowledge. The timings for the individual cues should never be taken seriously. 1½ min. might really mean ¾ min. or it might really mean 2¼ min. The hurried secretaries just plopped numbers in to fill the spaces. The official length of 7,500 feet was a vague guesstimation by someone who had not seen or measured the film, but who had heard that it was more than seven but less than eight reels. That guesstimation got into the official listings in 1926 and nobody has ever been able to shake it. The correct length is 7,084' or perhaps 7,085', and that is all. The first two preview prints may have been up to 80 or 90 feet longer, but not more than that. The “surprisingly unenthusiastic critical reception” was a retroactive and intentionally malicious garbling of the data by one Tom Dardis, whose pseudobiography had not yet been published but whose fake research was already beginning to pollute the biosphere. I do not fault Moews for these statements, since, at the time, what else could he have known, what else could he have concluded? Yet, thanks to this passage, there remain to this day Busterphiles who are convinced that 32.3fps is the correct speed, whereas Buster explicitly demanded 24fps, no faster, no slower. So there.

By the by, who is Daniel Donald Moews? (Or was his name Donald Daniel Moews?) Is he still amongst us? According to the inside flap, “Daniel Moews (pronounced ‘Maze’) has taught literature and film (including what he takes to be the first college course entirely devoted to the works of Buster Keaton — a man who, ‘sensibly enough, had only one day of formal schooling’). He now lives in California and is working on a book about silent-screen sentimentality, centering on Griffith, Chaplin, and Pickford.”
Be that as it may, I can learn little else about him. He was born in La Jolla on 28 May 1936. By 1954 he was attending high school in Wilmington, Illinois. In 1956 he was a student at Joliet Junior College, and resided at 1215 S 4th St in Champaign. In August 1963, he began teaching at the University of Wisconsin in Racine, as he was completing a Ph.D. thesis, which won him a doctorate on about 1 November 1963: Humanism and Ideology: A Study of Matthew Arnold’s Ideas on Man and Society.
On page vii of his Keaton book, Moews states: “One center of the current rediscovery is the National Film Theatre in London, and at a retrospective staged there in the summer of 1966, I first saw most of Keaton’s films.” There was a retrospective in the summer of 1966????? Methinks he was confused. The first Busterfest at the National Film Theatre was in January 1968.
Moews is the author of an article entitled “The ‘Prologue’ to ‘In Memoriam’: A Commentary on Lines 5, 17, and 32” in Victorian Poetry vol. 6, July 1968, p. 185. By the summer of 1969 he had transferred to the University of Wisconsin Green Bay and resided at 425 S Monroe Ave. I can find no other writings under his name.
After his Buster book, he seems to have vanished into a puff of smoke. There is no further record about him anywhere.




A Few Posters


One-sheet poster, also by Hap Hadley.


Another poster by Hap Hadley. I do not know the original size.




Window card.


Half-sheet, 22"×28".


Half-sheet, 22"×28".


Lobby title.


Netherlands, January 1927. Poster by Dolly Rudeman.


The Belgian première? Théâtre Tokio, 20-22, Rue Verlat. I think this was in Antwerp.
I can find no information on the Théâtre Tokio.


France, 24 February 1927?


Sweden, 28 February 1927?
Så går det till i krig (That’s How It’s Done in War)


Spain, teaser poster? 21 March 1927?


Germany, teaser poster? 4 April 1927

I cannot find any posters, but The General was released in Finland on 27 March 1927, under the title Krig og kærlighed (War and Love). On 7 April 1927, it opened in Hong Kong. On 11 February 1929, it finally made its way to Portugal, under the title A Glória de Pamplinas. It would be most interesting to collect info on all export releases, together with posters and any other documentation.

Why can I never find the poster for the original Italian release? An Italian colleague explained to me the most likely reason: There was no poster. For Italian movies of the time, each cinema set its own broadsides. There were no illustrated advertisements in the newspapers. My colleague did work out that The General opened in Turin on 19 October 1927, but its opening dates in other Italian cities remain a mystery. Ooooo. Ooooo. Ooooo. Ooooo. Ooooo. I just found some info on an eBay listing. The vendor, the soothingly named deportivolacargna, was vending a 1973 locandina for Our Hospitality (La legge dell’ ospitalità), eBay item number 283674054758, and in the item description wrote: “LOCANDINA ORIGINALE DA CINEMA. 70X33 CM CIRCA. Bellissimo disegno! 1'Edizione Italiana stampata nel 1973. (Il film prima del 1973 era uscito in Italia solo nel 1925 e non erano state stampate locandine!) Conservazione molto buona. Molto rara!” So there! There was never an Italian poster until decades later. My Italian colleague was right!

The Release

From Tom Dardis’s so-called biography, Keaton: The Man Who Wouldn’t Lie Down (NY: Scribner, 1979), p. 144:

It was NOT shown publicly in Los Ángeles on 22 December 1926. That was the date when the movie was copyrighted. The general release did NOT begin in February 1927, but on 11 December 1926. The earliest version was probably only 30 or 60 seconds longer than the one shown today. The early version(s) did NOT contain Snitz Edwards, who was in an abandoned scene that seems never to have been completed. The running time of the final film was NOT 82 minutes, but 79 minutes, assuming Buster’s preferred speed, which, beginning in late 1921, had become the most common speed in the US, namely, 90'/min. It’s not only movie scholarship that is conducted so shoddily. Pretty much all history is reconstructed at least this badly.


MORE OF THE ACCEPTED WISDOM. The accepted wisdom is that The General had its official world première on 31 December 1926, at “two small theatersin Tokyo, either for the reason that Buster wanted “to gauge audience reactions before screening it in the United States,” or for the reason that “Since United Artists was initially leery of offending viewers for whom the Civil War was still a fresh and wounding memory, The General opened first in two theaters in Tokyo, Japan, under the title Keaton, Shogun.” The accepted wisdom is that The General was not released in the US until Saturday, 5 February 1927, when it premièred at the Loew’s Capitol in Manhattan, NY. Accepted wisdom is that the original edition of the movie was three reels longer than it is now. Accepted wisdom bores me. The San Bernardino and San José preview screenings were essentially the film as we now have it, and the Glendale preview screening was almost exactly the edition that has come down to us, the only difference being the omission of a copyright credit. Movie historians tend not to be technicians, which is why a reel count trips them up. They think eleven reels is longer than eight reels. Seems logical, right? But two reels of 400 feet each last no longer on screen than one reel of 800 feet. The reel count isn’t the critical factor. The footage count is critical. Reel divisions are not set until after the final edit is complete.

Yes, as we shall learn below, the title was Kīton Shōgun when it opened in Tokyo. Why do the commonly wise who spout their common wisdom neglect to point out that Kīton Shōgun was also released elsewhere in Japan at the same time? Yes, it opened on the last day of 1926. The two cinemas in Tokyo were small????? Really? Small? Small compared to what, the Grand Canyon? The two Tokyo cinemas no longer exist, but the name of one of them was adopted by a dinky little 100-seat cinema, and apparently modern researchers assume the two buildings are the same building. They are not, not by any means. The enormous movie palace called the Meguro Kinema (1923–1945) is NOT the same as the modern 100-seat Meguro Cinema. I do not know how long the Japanese cinemas ran The General, nor do I know how many tickets they sold, nor do I know how that compared to average ticket sales or expected ticket sales, nor do I know what the contractual stipulations were, nor do I know what the rental was, or what the nut was, or what the profit was, or what the percentages were, or what all the newspaper ads looked like, or what the press releases stated, or what the reviews said, or where it played afterwards, or for how long. Why was the movie issued in Japan before it was issued in Manhattan? Well, let’s see. The booking in Manhattan was originally contracted for 1 January 1927, and the booking in Tokyo was only one day prior to that, 31 December 1926. That’s effectively no difference at all: New Year’s Eve as opposed to New Year’s Day. Such a momentary lead would hardly have given Buster the opportunity “to gauge audience reactions” — which he had already gauged three times over in California, anyway. As we all know by now, the NYC opening was delayed over a month due to circumstances beyond anybody’s control. Remember: The movie had already officially premièred on 11 December 1926 in Columbus, Ohio, after which it quickly spread, as we’ll see just below. What was so suspicious about spreading it to Japan three weeks after its US première? Listen closely. I need to whisper so that nobody will overhear our little secret. Here’s what happened: The UA office in Los Ángeles shipped some prints to the subsidiary in Tokyo, and the Tokyo subsidiary office then put the movie on the market, and exhibitors booked it. Wow. Who’d a thunk? It would be nice to find those first Japanese prints, but I doubt they exist anymore.

Not all newspapers are online, not all search queries work properly, and it would take many months of full-time labor to find every possible listing. We also need to remember that not all bookings were advertised in the newspapers. Back in those days, in many localities, the marquee and the poster windows were more than enough advertisement. So, the bookings listed below are the ones that can be discovered with online searches; they constitute only a small sampling of the total bookings.

The stills are all coded K27. The K, of course, is for Keaton Productions. The 27 is the number of the production. Three Ages was KN20. Our Hospitality was K21. Sherlock Jr. was K22. The Navigator was K23. Seven Chances was K24. Go West was K25. Battling Butler was K26. And so The General was K27. Simple.

The General —
Some Bookings That Pre-Date the NYC Première


Sat 11 Dec 1926 Columbus, OH James’ Grand Theatre 7 days  


Publicity.
“J. J.” was a staff reviewer at the Columbus Dispatch, but the full name is unknown.
This reads exactly like a press release, but it is, in fact, a review!
Wed 13 Dec 1926 Carnegie, OK Liberty Theatre 2 days  

Three weeks? More like nine weeks. Must have been a delay.
Fri 24 Dec 1926 Denton, TX Palace Theatre 2 days  
Sat 25 Dec 1926 El Paso, TX Palace Theatre 4 days  
Exhibitors Herald vol. 28 no. 2, Saturday, 25 December 1926, p. 7 :
Sun 26 Dec 1926 Bridgeport, CT Majestic Theatre 7 days  
Miss Any Train but This.
Mon 27 Dec 1926 Sumter, SC Lyric Theatre 2 days  
An ad and two press releases:
From Derbyshire, England, a press release I have not seen elsewhere.
The tale it tells seems apocryphal:
Fri 31 Dec 1926 Tokyo, Japan Imperial Pavilion ?????  
Images of the Imperial Pavilion, or Imperial Palace, or Imperial Theatre, or whatever its exact name was:





This was completely gutted and rebuilt for Cinerama, and then it was demolished altogether.
So Japan is no different from the US, huh?
Fri 31 Dec 1926 Tokyo, Japan Meguro Kinema ?????  
Unfortunately, I cannot find any illustrations of the Meguro Kinema. The Meguro Kinema in the Ōsaki section of Tokyo was a major movie palace that opened in 1923. It was operated by a Mr. Masuda and featured accompaniment by a full orchestra. It was destroyed in an air raid in 1945. Please do not be like modern researchers and confuse it with the current 100-seat Meguro Cinema. They are not the same at all.
A Japanese eBay vendor led me to a couple of Japanese blogs, and those Japanese blogs contained wondrous information. Above is an advertisement published in Kinema Junpo, Japan’s oldest movie magazine. I have Englished it below, as best as I could hammer out courtesy of Google Translator:
According to the blog where this is reproduced, this is an advertisement placed by the Imperial Pavilion and the Meguro Cinema. Whether this was printed in a newspaper or in a magazine or on a flyer, I don’t know. Since I’m illiterate, I broke this down section by section and ran each bit through Google Translator to arrive at some sort of knowledge of what is on this piece of paper. One line of text contains a single character that is too blotchy and thus defies Google Translator’s every attempt to read it. If you are Japanese and can make out what it says, please don’t keep secrets. Thanks! Several films are here advertised. We have The Great Grandma, or perhaps Grandma the Great, which is known in the US as Ella Cinders. There’s also something called Detective Agency and something else called Feeling Confused, and perhaps yet another, Queen of Smiles, though that latter may just be a tagline for Feeling Confused — or vice versa. The title of The General is wrongly rendered as 「キートン将軍」, or Kīton Shōgun, which I suppose translates General Keaton, which, of course, misses the point. An English version is also supplied, and it is somewhat more accurate: Keaton’s General.
Isn’t this outrageous? The advertisement falsely claims that this is the world première, when we know full well that it is anything but. If we are to give the advertisers the benefit of the doubt, perhaps there was a misunderstanding due to a less-than-satisfactory translation. This did indeed pre-date the scheduled NYC première, but only by a day. Yet it pre-dated the actual NYC première by more than a month, but the NYC delays were entirely unforeseen, due to circumstances beyond the distributor’s control. Nonetheless, the film had already been playing far and wide for three weeks in the US, and so the Tokyo screenings were far from world premières.
Fri 31 Dec 1926 Kobe, Japan Kinema Club ?????  
Fri 31 Dec 1926 Kyoto, Japan Shochikuza 2 days?  
Fri 31 Dec 1926 Nagoya, Japan Takada Sekaikan ?????  
Fri 31 Dec 1926 Tulsa, OK Rialto 11:30 sneak preview
Fri 31 Dec 1926 Paris, TX Plaza 2 days  
Fri 31 Dec 1926 San Diego, CA Balboa Theatre 1 show special 11:30pm show
Fri 31 Dec 1926 Portland, OR Majestic Theatre 1 show midnight preview
Fri 31 Dec 1926 Seattle, WA 5th Avenue Theatre 7 days  
Sat 01 Jan 1927 Kobe, Japan Shochikuza ?????  
Sun 02 Jan 1927 Rochester, NY Eastman Theatre 6 days Sun–Wed, Fri–Sat
Mon 03 Jan 1927 Pecos, TX Rialto Theatre 2 days  
Mon 03 Jan 1927 Corvallis, OR Whiteside Theatre 3 days comment
This is a press release, but the final sentence is a review:
Fri 06 Jan 1927 Osaka, Japan Shochikuza ?????  
Fri 06 Jan 1927? Amsterdam, NL Film-Praat (Luxor) ?????  
Fri 07 Jan 1927 Delta, UT Delta Theatre 2 days  
Fri 07 Jan 1927 Idabel, OK Lyric Theatre 2 days  
Sat 08 Jan 1927 Portland, OR Majestic Theatre 21 days promo














I do not know how to read the above box-office report. I require an expert to talk me through this data, but, in the meantime, let’s take a crack at it anyway. The Majestic had paid its “rental” to get the rights to show this movie. How much was the rental? I don’t know. Coulda been fifty bucks. Coulda been ten grand. I really don’t know, but I would hazard a guess that the rental would have been many thousands. The Majestic’s ticket prices are 35¢ matinées and 50¢ evenings, and I suppose the 25¢ tickets are for kids. We get the total lump sum, without breakdowns. The lump sum, by the way, is total ticket sales. The General opened on 8 January, and this report is submitted 10 days later, on 18 January, but since this is a weekly report, it probably refers only to Variety’s past fiscal week, 10–17 January. Probably. It might refer to the Majestic’s first fiscal week, 8–14 January. I don’t know. For this 1,000-seat house, $6,500 total ticket sales for the week is considered strong business. That’s more than 13,000 individual tickets. Now, there were no curtain times. The Majestic, like so many cinemas back in those days, was a “grind house.” The projectors’ gears began grinding around noon, then the doors opened, then passersby bought tickets and walked in whenever they felt like it. They would enter in mid-show and remain seated until they recognized something familiar from earlier. “This is where we came in.” The projectors’ gears would not stop grinding until around midnight, when the few stragglers were shooed out. So, how many times was The General shown each day? My guess is six times each day (noon, two, four, six, eight, ten), but I could very well be wrong about that. For the sake of argument, let us say that there were six shows a day. Six shows times 1,000 seats is 6,000 available seats each workday. Opening night was capacity business. The later nights were far from capacity business, but still pretty darned strong. The Majestic would deduct its operating expenses (its “nut”) and shoot over a percentage of the profit, probably 50%, but who knows? The distributor, United Artists, would accept that 50% or whatever, pay out its own costs, and divvy the remainder up with the producers and investors. What was the nut? What was the percentage? What were the costs? How exactly was the money divvied up? We may never find out.

Please note that $6,500/week was considered strong,
$3,000/week was considered “fair” but “holding up,”
but $5,000/week was “slipping.”
You figure it out. I give up.

Top image certainly by Melbourne Spurr, Hollywood.
Bottom image: K27-6.
Sat 08 Jan 1927 Tacoma, WA Rialto Theatre 7 days  
Thu 13 Jan 1927 Abilene, TX Majestic Theatre 1 day?  
Thu 13 Jan 1927 Altus, OK Wigwam Theatre 2 days  
Sat 15 Jan 1927 Chicago, IL Warner’s Orpheum Theatre 10 days review

Mae Tinée? Obviously a pseudonym. She was Frances Peck Grover (1886–1961), whose career at that paper lasted from 1911 through 1945. When she retired, Anna Nangle and later Clifford Terry adopted that sobriquet.
The unsigned review is by Carl Sandburg, noted biographer of Abraham Lincoln. The only reason we know that he is the author is because of a collection of his movie reviews in Arnie Bernstein, ed., “The Movies Are”: Carl Sandburg’s Film Reviews and Essays, 1920–1928 (Lake Claremont Press, 2000).



First week, $9,000. Second week, not-so-good $6,100.
I don’t understand.
The first week was seven days.
The second week was only three days.
On a day-by-day basis, it did better the second week. Yes?

Her followup review was kinder than her first.
Sat 15 Jan 1927 Kansas City, MO Liberty Theatre 7 days  
Sat 15 Jan 1927 Spokane, WA Liberty Theatre 7 days  
Sun 16 Jan 1927 Junction City, OR Rialto Theatre 3 days  
Sun 16 Jan 1927 Roseburg, OR Liberty Theatre 4 days ad
Mon 17 Jan 1927 London, England New Gallery 14 days press release
Fri 21 Jan 1927 Little Rock, AR Palace 2 days  
Sat 22 Jan 1927 Newark, NJ Mosque Theatre 7 days  
Sat 22 Jan 1927 Denver, CO America Theatre 8 days  
Sat 22 Jan 1927 Salem, OR Elsinore Theatre 3 days  
Mon 24 Jan 1927 Fairfield, CT Community Theatre 2 days  
Tue 25 Jan 1927 Dermott, AR Allied Theatre 1 day subrun
Tue 25 Jan 1927 Cottage Grove, OR Arcade Theatre 7 days Elbert Bede, editor of the Cottage Grove Sentinel, was he in the film?
Thu 27 Jan 1927 Medford, OR Hunt’s Craterian Theatre 3 days  
Sat 29 Jan 1927 Tulsa, OK Rialto 1 show children’s matinée
Sat 29 Jan 1927 Toledo, OH Loew’s Valentine 7 days  
Sun 30Jan 1927 Patchogue, NY Glynne’s Patchogue Theatre 3 days  
Sun 30 Jan 1927 Chattanooga, TN Tivoli Theatre 1 show private screening
Sun 30 Jan 1927 Lincoln, NE Orpheum Theatre 7 days  
Mon 31 Jan 1927 Reading, PA Loew’s Colonial Theatre 7 days  
Reads like a review, but it’s actually a press release:
Mon 31 Jan 1927 Columbia, SC Broadway Theatre 4 days  
Tue 01 Feb 1927 Tulsa, OK Rialto 2 days  
Thu 03 Feb 1927 Chattanooga, TN Tivoli Theatre 2 days?  
Thu 03 Feb 1927 Detroit, MI Broadway Strand Theatre 1 show private screening
Thu 03 Feb 1927 Lima, OH Lyric 5 days  
Thu 03 Feb 1927 Lebanon, OR Kuhn Theatre 3 days  


Do you notice something a little bit odd about that list above? Films normally opened in deluxe houses in the largest downtowns first (including Broadway, Boston, Philly, Chicago, Detroit, and, a bit later, SF and LÁ), and then in the neighborhood cinemas and the suburbs, and then in smaller cities, and finally in rural villages. The list above (which is based only on newspaper archives easily available online, and nothing more) demonstrates that the release of The General was somewhat haphazard. Why? I do not know, but we need to remember that United Artists had not yet built up a major cinema chain. It had to negotiate with rivals in order to get its films shown, and that likely was a major factor in this unusual distribution pattern.

Let’s take a break for a moment, because it was probably right around this time that a book was published.

The Novelization

Yes, there was a novelization by a Joseph Warren, published in 1927 by Grosset & Dunlap. These novelizations were the closest movie fans could get to VHS or DVD. They kept the memories a little bit alive. I purchased a copy from Hammond’s Antiques sometime around 1998 or 1999 for the whopping price of $16. I purchased it partly out of curiosity and partly in the hope that it might solve the mystery of some of those stills that correspond to nothing in the film as we know it. Alas, it solves none of those mysteries. I attempted to read it, but was unable to get more than a few pages into it. A visual story should not be converted to a verbal story, just as a ballet should not be told as a limerick. It cannot work, and it does not work, and the book is far too painful for me to read. Who was this Joseph Warren? Does anybody know? Here is the dust jacket as posted on WorthPoint:


K27-158

NYC



The General —
The Manhattan Opening, Saturday, 5 February 1927


For reasons unknown to me, despite the above promise, The General did not open at Loew’s Capitol on New Year’s Day. Instead, an MGM picture called A Little Journey, with William Haines, opened on that day. That film seems no longer to exist, by the way. Then, the following week, on 8 January 1927, The General was bumped yet again, to make way for yet another MGM picture, this one called Flesh and the Devil. I guess that Loew’s, which owned MGM, decided that MGM movies can bump movies from such upstart organizations as United Artists. Remember, when Loew’s booked MGM movies, money was effectively being moved from one pocket to the other. When Loew’s booked movies from other distributors, some of the profit left the home company and migrated elsewhere, which was a bit of a disincentive to book outside product. Flesh and the Devil was a slick but corny soap opera about shallow selfish toxic people doing shallow selfish toxic things for two agonizingly long hours, and so it was expected to do exceptional business. That is why it was booked for a two-week run. It did much better business than expected, and so it was held for yet another two weeks, which was extremely unusual. It was still doing enough business to justify a fifth week, but the bosses decided, at long last, to honor the contract with United Artists and bring in The General, which ran the usual one week.

This tiny article is really hard to find, as it appeared only in the Home Edition and the Wall Street Edition of that day’s newspaper. Making it even more confusing, the online archive indexes this not under The Brooklyn Daily Times, but under Times Union.



On Broadway in Manhattan, The General opened at the Loew’s Capitol, which at the time was the world’s largest cinema, with 5,450 seats. Two months later, it would be outdone by the 6,214-seat Roxy. Despite the luxury, it appears that the Capitol was a grind house with continuous performances. That was so horribly typical back then. As we shall discover below, the program, which included The General, some short films, musical interludes, and a stage attraction, ran just a few minutes shy of two hours. I do not know what time the doors opened in the day, nor do I know what time the audience was chased away at night, but a reasonable guess is a noon opening and a midnight closing. With a continuous show just under two hours long, we can assume six shows a day: noon, two, four, six, eight, ten, give or take a few minutes here and there. Six times 5,450 seats is a potential of 32,700 tickets available each day. Multiply that by seven days, and that is a maximum potential of 228,900 tickets available each week. No cinema could possibly sell that many tickets in a week. The reason cinemas were so large was simply to get more favorable treatment from studios and distributors. This is why cinemas were usually built into skyscrapers or into larger complexes: The rentals from the other units subsidized the cinemas, which otherwise would be unaffordable. It was a symbiotic relationship. The businesses in the other units were happy to subsidize the cinemas, because the cinemas brought more customers to the area. That was nothing new. Over the previous century, stage theatres had operated under that same principle. What sort of business did the Capitol normally do? For December 1926, only a single figure is available free online:

To get the figures for the rest of that month would require a trip to the library. We can see here that there were two ticket prices, 50¢ either for matinées or kiddies or both, and $1.65 for grownups at the evening performances. The Flaming Forest is not a kiddie flick, and so most tickets were probably to grownups. We don’t have a proper breakdown, but let’s try this anyway, let’s divide $59,751.75 by $1.65 and see what happens: About 36,213 tickets sold, and it was surely a bit more than that, if only we could factor in the 50¢ tickets. Out of a potential 228,900 tickets, a bit more than 36,213 were sold. Do you begin to see the problem that enormous cinemas pose?

I got to the library.



Oops. The others didn’t download properly. Need to go back to the library.

The next freely available info is from January, and you now know enough to perform the arithmetic, if that tickles your fancy:

All right. Now you have some context. You never had a context before. Now you have a context. The final week of Flesh and the Devil had $56,031 in ticket sales, almost all to grownups, since no kiddies anywhere would have the slightest interest, which proves that kiddies are sometimes far more emotionally mature than their mommies and daddies. The Loew’s Capitol management concluded that it would have been better to keep Flesh and the Devil for a fifth week rather than to ship it out and replace it with The General, which, as we shall discover shortly, drew $50,992 in its only week, with probably half of the tickets sold to kiddies at the reduced moppet rate. Now you REALLY have a context. It’s not a perfect context, it’s not a complete context, but it’s a CONTEXT, and with that context you can pretty much figure out what was happening. The number of tickets sold during the sole week of The General was certainly higher than the number of tickets sold during the fourth-and-final week of Flesh and the Devil, though the revenues were slightly less because of kiddie prices. Ticket sales and box-office were comparable to those of a normal week, upper range of normal. What we do not know are the costs. It is certain that the Flesh and the Devil contract had more favorable terms, because, after all, it was an in-house production. What were the contractual terms for The General? I don’t know. Do you?

Okay. We got that out of the way. Now let’s look at a trade review, a description of the overall show, and a little more data. The trade review by Freddie Schader (Variety sig: “Fred.”) was thoroughly negative, downright hostile, which is okay. What the heck? It’s an opinion. People have opinions. Big deal. Freddie just did not like Buster at all, in any way, found nothing about his movies funny or worthwhile. See his hostile review of Sherlock Jr., in which we can see that Buster just wasn’t his cup of tea. Freddie’s problem was that he was convinced that if he didn’t like Buster, then it logically followed that NOBODY did. What bothers me about Freddie’s review of The General is that it contained a lie. You are now in a position to spot the lie. (Note the running time: 77 minutes; if that was clocked accurately, then the projectionist turned up the speed the tiniest little tad, to about 92'/min rather than the usual 90'/min. Next time a scholar tells you that The General in its original release was overspeeded to run a mere 62 minutes, slap him in the face with Freddie’s review.)


The issue is dated the 12th, one day after The General completed its run at Loew’s Capitol. My guess is that The New Yorker was on newsstands several days prior to the cover date. Nice to learn a bit more about the newsreel ahead of the feature.



Post-NYC

The General —
Some Bookings That Post-Date the NYC Première


Sat 05 Feb 1927 Detroit, MI Broadway Strand Theatre 7 days Herbert Brenon
Sun 06 Feb 1927 Buffalo, NY Lafayette Theatre 7 days  

There ya go! High overhead.
Zo, The General was overpriced and preventing cinemas from getting returns on their investments.
Very interesting.
(Sun 06 Feb 1927) (Ithaca, NY) (Strand Theatre) 3 days (double bill with Just Another Blonde, but The General was canceled and replaced with Battling Butler.)
Sun 06 Feb 1927 Dayton, OH State Theatre 7 days  

As you can see, this item consists of a few random, unconnected lines of an earlier NEA (Newspaper Enterprise Association) syndicated press release, which you can see above, at 11 January. I want to know more about this Confederate General R. de T. Lawrence, biographer of his dear friend, a slave named Bill Yopp.
Mon 07 Feb 1927 Boston, MA Loew’s State 7 days  
Not a review, but it might as well be one:
Mon 07 Feb 1927 Albany, NY Mark-Strand Theatre 7 days  
ca. 07 Feb 1927 Bethlehem, PA Colonial ?????  
Mon 07 Feb 1927 Harrisburg, PA Loew’s Regent Theatre 7 days  
Mon 07 Feb 1927 Eugene, OR McDonald Theatre 4 days press release
Tue 08 Feb 1927 Havana, Cuba Teatro Prado 2 days  
Tue 08 Feb 1927 Havana, Cuba Teatro Rialto 2 days  
Tue 08 Feb 1927 North Adams, MA Empire 2 days  
Wed 09 Feb 1927 La Crosse, WI Cooper’s New Bijou 4 days  
Not a review, but a press release, once again:
Fri 11 Feb 1927 Rochester, NY Strand Theatre 2 days second run

K27-206
Buster Keaton is at the Capitol in a quiet and unassuming comedy entitled THE GENERAL. There is nothing raucus about it, and, let us light a candle, there is no pathos, and it is altogether a pleasant relaxation. What is even more to its credit, a new type of heroine makes herself evident, and a new treatment of the lady is indulged in. She is terribly inefficient, and her attempts to be of service during emergencies are all dismal failures. That is something, of course, but on top of that departure from the standard, the girl is subjected to a mass of indignities. She is tied in a sack and put where stevedores throw barrels and packing cases on top of her. The hero chokes her after one of her little blunders, and when she perpetrates an act of considerable stupidity he hurls a log of wood at her. That may not be an inspiring light for American womanhood to be placed in, but it is certainly a novel one.
Marian Mack takes the part and she does so with great good humor and willingness and I hope she has completely recovered from any bruises she may have suffered during the taking of the picture.
Such things are all part of a gentle kidding of the Civil War story. Keaton is a locomotive engineer who tries to be the first to enlist, but the Confederacy won’t have him. Later the Federal troops steal his engine and he pursues in another, rescues his girl, and is chased back to where he started. He recovers his locomotive, saves the army, is accepted in the service and reaps romance. Most of the action takes place on the engines, and it is laid out with more wit than wisecracking.
Sat 12 Feb 1927 Springfield, OR Bell Theatre 4 days  
Sat 12 Feb 1927 Vancouver, WA U.S.A. 3 days  
Fri 11 Feb 1927 Atlanta, GA Confederate Soldiers’ Home 1 show special screening
Sun 13 Feb 1927 Pittsburgh, PA Loew’s Aldine 7 days  
Mon 14 Feb 1927 Norfolk, VA Loew’s State 7 days  
Sun 13 Feb 1927 Atlanta, GA Loew’s Grand Theatre 7 days  

Says Sara Zittel: “long line to see Buster Keaton in The General
Mon 14 Feb 1927 Fitchburg, MA Shea’s Theater 3 days
Mon 14 Feb 1927 Pittsfield, MA Palace Theater 3 days PR
Mon 14 Feb 1927 Pittsburgh, PA Loew’s Aldine 5 days  
Mon 14 Feb 1927 Memphis, TN Loew’s State 7 days
Tue 15 Feb 1927 West Palm Beach, FL Beaux Arts Theatre 2 days

K27-66

K27-97
Haven’t yet figured out where this was.

Fri 18 Feb 1927 Miami, FL Community Theatre 2 days  


Sat 19 Feb 1927 Oklahoma City, OK Capitol 4 days  
Sat 19 Feb 1927 Salt Lake, UT Paramount Empress 7 days  
Sun 20 Feb 1927 Cleveland, OH Allen Theatre 7 days  

K27-206
Sun 20 Feb 1927 Miami, FL Coconut Grove Theatre 2 days move-over
Sun 20 Feb 1927 Gunnison, CO Unique Theatre 2 days  
Sun 20 Feb 1927 Heppner, OR Star Theater 2 days  
Sun 20 Feb 1927 Montréal, QC Loew’s 7 days  
Mon 21 Feb 1927 Boston, MA Loew’s Orpheum 7 days second run
Mon 21 Feb 1927 Manhattan, NY Metropolitan Theatre 7 days second run


Mon 21 Feb 1927 Manhattan, NY Loew’s State Theatre 7 days second run
Mon 21 Feb 1927 Boston, MA Loew’s Orpheum 7 days  
Mon 21 Feb 1927 Dover, NJ Baker Theatre 3 days  

No, not all critics agreed. That’s one huge strike against this press release. It did not play to capacity audiences at each performance at the Capitol. If it had, it would have been held over, and that would have been a world record.
Mon 21 Feb 1927 State College, PA Cauthaum Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 21 Feb 1927 State College, PA Nittany Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 21 Feb 1927 Nashville, TN Loew’s Vendome 6 days  
Mon 21 Feb 1927 South Bend, IN Blackstone Theatre 7 days  
Mon 21 Feb 1927 Springfield, MO Gillioz 4 days subrun
Mon 21 Feb 1927 Manhattan, KS Miller 3 days subrun
Mon 21 Feb 1927 Norman, OK University Theatre 2 days  
Thu 24 Feb 1927 Canonsburg, PA Beedle’s Alhambra 2 days subrun
Thu 24 Feb 1927 Knoxville, TN Riviera 3 days review, review
Sat 26 Feb 1927 Syracuse, NY Strand Theatre 7 days  

Despite the byline, this review was written by an “F.C.,” whose identity is a mystery to me.
Sat 26 Feb 1927 Houston, TX Capitol 7 days  
Mon 28 Feb 1927 Indiana, PA Ritz Theatre 3 days subrun
Mon 28 Feb 1927 Neosho, MO Orpheum 2 days subrun
Tue 01 Mar 1927 West Palm Beach, FL Stanley Theatre 2 days second run
Fri 04 Mar 1927 Manhattan, NY Loew’s 116th St. 3 days second run
Fri 04 Mar 1927 Las Vegas, NV Majestic 2 days  

The quote from the Commercial Appeal is from a local press release, not from a review.
The other quote, about Loew’s Grand in Atlanta, I cannot find that anywhere, and I suspect it was just made up for this advertisement.
Mon 07 Mar 1927 Bradenton, FL Wallace Theatre 2 days  
Mon 07 Mar 1927 Seminole, OK State Theatre 1 show State grand opening
Mon 07 Mar 1927 Calgary, AB Palace 6 days  
Tue 08 Mar 1927 Brattleboro, VT Princess Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 10 Mar 1927 Brooklyn, NY Loew’s Gates Theatre 3 days  
Thu 10 Mar 1927 Brooklyn, NY Bedford Theatre 3 days  
Thu 10 Mar 1927 Brooklyn, NY Premier Theatre 3 days  
Thu 10 Mar 1927 Pittsburgh, PA Garden 3 days second run
ca 10 Mar 1927 Galion, OH Royal Theatre ???  
Thu 10 Mar 1927 Kansas City, MO Madrid 3 days second run
Fri 11 Mar 1927 Brewster, NY Cameo Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 11 Mar 1927 Kansas City, MO Apollo 2 days second run
Fri 11 Mar 1927 Warrenton, MO New Warrenton Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 11 Mar 1927 Aline, OK Community Theatre 2 days subrun
ca. 11 Mar 1927 Boise, ID Pinney Theatre 1 show preview
Fri 11 Mar 1927 Los Ángeles, CA Metropolitan Theatre (Publix) 7 days review, review
Ah. I see that Jim Curtis (p. 319) has something I don’t have, namely, the review published in The Los Ángeles Evening Herald, 12 March 1927. Since I don’t have the clipping — yet — I’ll cheat by quoting from Jim:

The venue was Sid Grauman’s 3,600-seat Metropolitan, the largest movie palace in the city, and the opening was set for Friday, March 11, with more than fifty picture personalities in attendance, headed by a contingent of United Artists stars that included Keaton and Marion Mack, Norma and Constance Talmadge, Estelle Taylor, and John Barrymore. Heralded by sun arcs and banks of Klieg lights illuminating the theater’s Sixth Street entrance, as well as a performance by the 160th Infantry Band of the California National Guard, the film packed the theater “to within an inch from the roof.” According to the Los Ángeles Evening Herald, “uproarious applause” greeted every appearance Keaton made on-screen, and “torrents of laughter” flowed without interruption. “Buster was in the audience last night along with a number of other film celebrities and he received an ovation that must certainly have inspired one of those rare smiles that optimistic fans have as yet failed to see.”



Sat 12 Mar 1927 St. Louis, MO Loew’s State 7 days review, review
Sat 12 Mar 1927 Lawton, OK Rialto 4 days
Sun 13 Mar 1927 New Rochelle, NY Loew’s Main St. Theatre 3 days  
Mon 14 Mar 1927 Pottsville, PA Capitol 2 days subrun
Mon 14 Mar 1927 Baltimore, MD Loew’s Century Theatre 6 days review
Mon 14 Mar 1927 Charleston, WV Kearse Theatre 3 days  
Wed 16 Mar 1927 Albany, NY Colonial 1 day second run
Thu 17 Mar 1927 White Plains, NY State Theatre 3 days  
Thu 17 Mar 1927 Buffalo, NY Shea’s North Park (Publix) 3 days second run
Thu 17 Mar 1927 Charlotte, NC Imperial 3 days  
Thu 17 Mar 1927 Rockford, IL Midway 3 days  
Fri 18 Mar 1927 Kansas City, MO Linwood 2 days second run
Sun 20 Mar 1927 Bronx, NY Kameo Theatre 2 days second run
Sun 20 Mar 1927 Miami, FL Hippodrome 3 days second run
Sun 20 Mar 1927 Detroit, MI Regent 7 days second run
Sun 20 Mar 1927 Chehalis, WA St. Helens 2 days subrun
Sun 20 Mar 1927 Helena, MT Marlow 2 days subrun
Mon 21 Mar 1927 New York, NY Lafayette Theatre 7 days  
Sun 20 Mar 1927 Hempstead, NY Hempstead Theatre 4 days subrun
Mon 21 Mar 1927 Daytona Beach, FL Vivian 2 days  
Mon 21 Mar 1927 Frederick, OK A-Mus-U 1 day subrun
Mon 21 Mar 1927 Holdenville, OK Dixie Theatre 3 days  
Tue 22 Mar 1927 Mineola, NY Mineola Theatre 1 day subrun
Wed 23 Mar 1927 Yonkers, NY Strand Theatre 3 days  
Wed 23 Mar 1927 Pittsburgh, PA Triangle 2 days third run
Thu 24 Mar 1927 Freeport, NY Grove Theatre 3 days  
Thu 24 Mar 1927 Kansas City, MO Benton 2 days second run
Thu 24 Mar 1927 San Bernardino, CA West Coast Theatre 3 days  
Fri 25 Mar 1927 Omaha, NE Sun 7 days review, birthday promo

K27-206
Fri 25 Mar 1927 Henryetta, OK Blaine Theatre 2 days subrun
Sat 26 Mar 1927 San Diego, CA Balboa Theatre 2 days  
Sun 27 Mar 1927 Philadelphia, PA Fox Theatre 7 days  
Sun 27 Mar 1927 Lawrenceburg, IN Walnut Theatre 3 days  
Sun 27 Mar 1927 Milwaukee, WI Alhambra 6 days  
Sun 27 Mar 1927 Kansas City, MO Tivoli 2 days second run
Mon 28 Mar 1927 Boston, MA Allston 2 days second run
Mon 28 Mar 1927 Cocoa, FL Aladdin Theatre 1 day  
Mon 28 Mar 1927 Pomona, CA California Theatre 3 days  
Mon 28 Mar 1927 San Pedro, CA Cabrillo Theatre 7 days promo
Wed 30 Mar 1927 Butte, MT American 3 days subrun
Wed 30 Mar 1927 Kansas City, MO Neptune 2 days second run
Wed 30 Mar 1927 Olympia, WA Liberty (Pac. NW) 3 days  
Thu 31 Mar 1927 St. Albans, VT Empire Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 31 Mar 1927 Kenmore, NY Shea’s Kenmore (Publix) 2 days second run
Thu 31 Mar 1927 Wichita Falls, TX Olympic 3 days subrun
Fri 01 Apr 1927 Minneapolis, MN Garrick 7 days PR
Fri 01 Apr 1927 El Centro, CA West Coast Valley 2 days subrun
Sat 02 Apr 1927 Montréal, QC Westmount 1 day second run
Sun 03 Apr 1927 Washington, DC Loew’s Palace Theatre 7 days  
Sun 03 Apr 1927 Louisville, KY Kentucky 4 days doubled with The Masked Woman
Sun 03 Apr 1927 North Kansas City, MO Capitol Theatre 2 days second run
Sun 03 Apr 1927 Lewiston, ID Liberty 3 days  
Sun 03 Apr 1927 Los Ángeles, CA Sunbeam 2 days second run
Sun 03 Apr 1927 Pasadena, CA Florence Theatre 4 days held over for 5th day
Sun 03 Apr 1927 Portland, OR Circle Theatre 2 days
Sun 03 Apr 1927 Portland, OR Hudson’s Colonial 2 days
Mon 04 Apr 1927 Germany Berliner Capitol and numerous others throughout the country ?????  

Can any Germans help with this? Parts of it are too blurred for me to decipher. It looks like an extremely favorable review (“One of the funniest pieces from the American film industry”), from what little I can make out.
Mon 04 Apr 1927 Montréal, QC Regent 3 days  
Mon 04 Apr 1927 Lynbrook, NY Lynbrook 4 days subrun
Mon 04 Apr 1927 Valley Stream, NY Valley Stream 2 days subrun
Mon 04 Apr 1927 Chattanooga, TN American 2 days subrun
Mon 04 Apr 1927 Guymon, OK Royal Theatre 2 days subrun
Wed 06 Apr 1927 North Adams, MA Photoplay 3 days subrun
Wed 06 Apr 1927 Lynbrook, NY Lynbrook 2 days return
Thu 07 Apr 1927 Portland, ME Strand 3 days  
Thu 07 Apr 1927 Kansas City, MO Oak Park 2 days second run
Thu 07 Apr 1927 Denver, CO Ogden 2 days second run
Fri 08 Apr 1927 Portland, OR Egyptian 1 day second run
Sun 10 Apr 1927 Portland, OR Venetian 2 days second run
Sat 09 Apr 1927 Scarsdale, NY Scarsdale Theatre 1 day  
Sun 10 Apr 1927 Philadelphia, PA Victoria 7 days second run, PR
Sun 10 Apr 1927 Denver, CO Alpine 2 days second run
Sun 10 Apr 1927 Boise, ID Strand 4 days  
Mon 11 Apr 1927 Kansas City, MO Belmont 1 day second run
Mon 11 Apr 1927 Wynnewood, OK Deal Theatre 2 days subrun
Wed 13 Apr 1927 Coshocton, OH Chocos Bros. Pastime 3 days  
Wed 13 Apr 1927 Austin, TX Hancock Opera House 4 days kiddie matinée
An editorial, not a review:
Thu 14 Apr 1927 Scarsdale, NY Scenic Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 14 Apr 1927 Sioux Falls, SD State Theatre 3 days subrun
Thu 14 Apr 1927 Kansas City, MO Prospect 2 days second run
Thu 14 Apr 1927 Waco, TX Hippodrome 3 days subrun
Thu 14 Apr 1927 Boise, ID Majestic 4 day move-over
Fri 15 Apr 1927(?) Dewey, OK Liberty 2 days subrun
Fri 15 Apr 1927 Beaumont, TX Tivoli 2 days subrun
Sat 16 Apr 1927 Bartlesville, OK Liberty 1 day subrun
Sun 17 Apr 1927 Coral Gables, FL Coral Gables Theatre 1 day  
Sun 17 Apr 1927 New Orleans, LA Loew’s State 7 days  
Sun 17 Apr 1927 Denver, CO Queen (D&R) 3 days second run
Sun 17 Apr 1927 Portland, OR Bagdad 2 days second run
Sun 17 Apr 1927 Redondo, CA Capitol Theatre 3 days subrun
Sun 17 Apr 1927 Montréal, QC Amherst 3 days second run
Mon 18 Apr 1927 Baltimore, MD Ideal 1 day second run
Mon 18 Apr 1927 Baltimore, MD Rialto 1 day second run
Mon 18 Apr 1927 Kansas City, MO Baltis 1 day second run
Mon 18 Apr 1927 Waxahachie, TX Dixie 2 days subrun
Tue 19 Apr 1927 Greenfield, MA Lawler Theatre 2 days 2nd to Fashions for Women
Tue 19 Apr 1927 Middlebury, VT Middlebury Opera House 1 day subrun
Wed 20 Apr 1927 St. Petersburg, FL Florida Theatre 2 days  
Wed 20 Apr 1927 Los Ángeles, CA Manchester 3 days second run
Wed 20 Apr 1927 Tacoma, WA K Street Theatre 2 days second run
Thu 21 Apr 1927 Baltimore, MD Broadway 2 days second run
Thu 21 Apr 1927 Monroe, LA Saenger 1 day subrun
Thu 21 Apr 1927 Wolf Point, MT Liberty 2 days subrun
Thu 21 Apr 1927 Kansas City, MO New Centre 1 day second run
Sat 23 Apr 1927 Chester, PA Washington (Stanley) 1 day subrun
Sat 23 Apr 1927 Baltimore, MD Columbia 1 day second run
Sat 23 Apr 1927 Sydney NSW Haymarket 6 days  
Sun 24 Apr 1927 Miami, FL Rosetta Theatre 1 day third run
Sun 24 Apr 1927 Eau Claire, WI Wisconsin 3 days subrun
Sun 24 Apr 1927 Kansas City, MO Beaufort 2 days second run
Sun 24 Apr 1927 Kansas City, MO Colonial 2 days second run
Sun 24 Apr 1927 Burbank, CA Victory Theatre 2 days subrun
Sun 24 Apr 1927 Portland, OR Chaldean 2 days second run
Tue 26 Apr 1927 Tacoma, WA Sunset 3 days second run
Wed 27 Apr 1927 Johnson City, TN Majestic 1 day subrun
Thu 28 Apr 1927 Montréal, QC Papineau 2 days second run, double bill
Thu 28 Apr 1927 Buffalo, NY Rivoli 2 days second run
Thu 28 Apr 1927 Medina, NY Allen 3 days subrun
Thu 28 Apr 1927 Brainerd, MN Lyceum 2 days subrun
Fri 29 Apr 1927 Fitchburg, MA Grand Theatre 2 days second run
Fri 29 Apr 1927 Lathrop, MO Lathrop Theatre 2 days subrun
ca 30 Apr 1927 Quincy, IL Orpheum Theatre ?????  
ca 30 Apr 1927 Quincy, IL Washington Theatre ?????  
Sat 30 Apr 1927 Bellingham, WA Avalon Theater 4 days  
Sun 01 May 1927 St. Louis, MO Union 1 day second run
Sun 01 May 1927 Phoenix, AZ Columbia 7 days  
Sun 01 May 1927 Portland, OR State 2 days second run
Mon 02 May 1927 Hannibal, MO Orpheum (Quincy) 3 days subrun
Tue 03 May 1927 Chandler, AZ Rowena Theater 1 day  
Tue 03 May 1927 Denver, CO Isis 2 days second run
Wed 04 May 1927 Jackson, MS Istrione 1 day subrun
Wed 04 May 1927 South Bend, IN Tivoli 2 days second run
Thu 05 May 1927 Lancaster, PA Capitol 7 days  
Fri 06 May 1927 Tempe, AZ Menhennett 1 day subrun
Fri 06 May 1927 Montréal, QC Corona 2 days second run, double bill
Sat 07 May 1927 Jasper, MO Liberty 1 day subrun
Sat 07 May 1927 Kansas City, MO Bonaventure 1 day second run
Sat 07 May 1927 Denver, CO Bluebird 1 day second run
Mon 09 May 1927 Mount Rainier, MD Cameo Theater 2 days subrun
Mon 09 May 1927 Auckland, NZ West End 2 days  
Tue 10 May 1927 Tacoma, WA Liberty 3 days second run
Wed 11 May 1927 Montréal, QC Maisonneuve Theatre
2677 Ontario St E
3 days? third run
Thu 12 May 1927 Boston, MA University 3 days second run
Thu 12 May 1927 Baltimore, MD Capitol 2 days second run
Fri 13 May 1927 Gaithersburg, MD Lyric 2 days subrun, Grand Opening
Fri 13 May 1927 St. Louis, MO Kings Theater 1 day second run
Sun 15 May 1927 Tulsa, OK Main Street 3 days second run
Sun 15 May 1927 Casa Grande, AZ Oasis 2 days subrun
Sun 19 May 1927 Tucson, AZ Rialto 3 days
Mon 16 May 1927 Harrisburg, PA Broad 3 days second run
Mon 16 May 1927 York, PA Hippodrome 7 days subrun
Mon 16 May 1927 Portsmouth, VA Tivoli 3 days subrun
Tue 17 May 1927 Hudson Falls, NY Strand Theatre 1 day  
Wed 18 May 1927 Waterville, ME Opera House 1½ days  
Wed 18 May 1927 Baltimore, MD Avalon 2 days third run
Wed 18 May 1927 Chickasha, OK Rialto 1 day subrun
Thu 19 May 1927 Philadelphia, PA 333 Market 3 days third run
Thu 19 May 1927 Santa Fé, NM Paris Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 20 May 1927 Buffalo, NY Shea’s Elmwood (Publix) 2 days second run
Fri 20 May 1927 Hagerstown, MD Maryland 2 days subrun
Fri 20 May 1927 Minneapolis, MN Loring 2 days second run
Sat 21 May 1927 Los Ángeles, CA Hollyway 1 day second run
Sun 22 May 1927 Allentown, PA State 7 days  
Sun 22 May 1927 Winona, MN Winona 2 days subrun
Sun 22 May 1927 Kansas City, MO Diana 2 days second run
Sun 22 May 1927 El Reno, OK Criterion 3 days subrun
Sun 22 May 1927 Portland, OR Irvington 2 days second run
Mon 23 May 1927 Rutland, VT Strand 2 days subrun
Mon 23 May 1927 Akron, NY Akron High School Auditorium 1 show special
Mon 23 May 1927 Kansas City, MO Powhatan 1 day doubled with Stella Dallas
Tue 24 May 1927 Minneapolis, MN Rialto 3 days second run
Tue 24 May 1927 Kansas City, MO Murray 1 day second run
Wed 25 May 1927 Poughkeepsie, NY Liberty Theatre 2 days  
Thu 26 May 1927 Pittsburgh, PA Colonial 2 days third run
Thu 26 May 1927 St. Louis, MO Congress 3 days second run
Fri 27 May 1927 Augusta, ME Colonial 2 days  
Fri 27 May 1927 Pensacola, FL Saenger Theatre 1 day  
Fri 27 May 1927 Mesa, AZ Niles 1 day  
Sat 28 May 1927 St. Louis, MO Woodland 1 day second run
Sat 28 May 1927 San Pedro, CA Strand 1 day second run
Sun 29 May 1927 Casper, WY America 3 days subrun
Sun 29 May 1927 Lents, OR Yeager 2 days subrun
Mon 30 May 1927 Hull, Eng Cecil 6 days
Mon 30 May 1927 Syracuse, NY Palace Theatre 2 days second run
Mon 30 May 1927 Baltimore, MD Ritz 1 day third run
Mon 30 May 1927 Chippewa Falls, WI Rex 2 days subrun
Mon 30 May 1927 Victoria, BC Coliseum Theatre, 1609 Government St nr Johnson St 7 days  
Wed 01 Jun 1927 Baltimore, MD Red Wing 2 days third run
Wed 01 Jun 1927 Sheboygan, WI Rex 4 days subrun
Thu 02 Jun 1927 Buffalo, NY Victoria Theatre (Indep.) 2 days third run
Thu 02 Jun 1927 Minneapolis, MN Lyndale 2 days second run
Thu 02 Jun 1927 Windsor, ON Walkerville Theatre 3 days subrun
Fri 03 Jun 1927 St. Louis, MO Kingsland 1 day third run
Fri 03 Jun 1927 Sapulpa, OK Victorian 2 days subrun
Sat 04 Jun 1927 Southampton, NY Garden Theatre 1 day third run
Sat 04 Jun 1927 Altoona, PA State 7 days 2nd to The Night Bride
Sat 04 Jun 1927 Philadelphia, PA Colonial 1 day third run
Sat 04 Jun 1927 Kansas City, MO South Troost 1 day third run
Sun 05 Jun 1927 Kansas City, MO Waldo 2 days third run
Sun 05 Jun 1927 Okmulgee, OK Yale 2 days subrun
Mon 06 Jun 1927 L’Anse, MI New Mazda 2 days subrun
Tue 07 Jun 1927 Washington, DC Crandall’s Avenue Grand 2 days second run
Tue 07 Jun 1927 Miami, FL Paramount Theatre 2 days third run
Thu 09 Jun 1927 Lewiston, ME Empire 3 days subrun
Thu 09 Jun 1927 Washington, DC Tivoli Theatre 2 days second run
Fri 10 Jun 1927 Buffalo, NY Regent (Indep.) 2 days third run
Fri 10 Jun 1927 St. Louis, MO Pageant 1 day third run
Fri 10 Jun 1927 St. Louis, MO Tivoli 1 day third run
Fri 10 Jun 1927 Ogden, UT Paramount 2 days subrun
Sat 11 Jun 1927 Indianapolis, IN Colonial 7 days  
Mon 13 Jun 1927 Holyoke, MA Strand 7 days subrun
Tue 14 Jun 1927 Washington, DC Crandall’s Apollo Theatre 2 days second run
Wed 15 Jun 1927 Warsaw, NY O-At-Ka Theatre 2 days second run
Wed 15 Jun 1927 Knoxville, TN Queen Theatre 2 days second run
Wed 15 Jun 1927 Reno, NV Majestic Theatre 4 days  
Thu 16 Jun 1927 Bangor, ME Opera House 3 days subrun
Thu 16 Jun 1927 Chambersburg, PA Capitol Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 16 Jun 1927 Philadelphia, PA Keystone 3 days third run
Thu 16 Jun 1927 Philadelphia, PA Logan 3 days third run
Thu 16 Jun 1927 Muncie, IN Columbia 3 days subrun
Fri 17 Jun 1927 Allentown, PA Lyric 2 days second run
Fri 17 Jun 1927 Corsicana, TX Palace 2 days subrun
Sat 18 Jun 1927 Washington, DC Crandall’s Ambassador Theatre 1 day second run
Sat 18 Jun 1927 Washington, DC Crandall’s Home Theatre 1 day second run
Sat 18 Jun 1927 Chattanooga, TN Rivoli 1 day second run
Sat 18 Jun 1927 Mansfield, OH Ritz 3 days subrun
Sat 18 Jun 1927 Greenwood, IN Community Theatre 1 day  
Sun 19 Jun 1927 Racine, WI Rialto 1 day subrun
Wed 22 Jun 1927 Lake Placid, NY Palace 1 day subrun
Wed 22 Jun 1927 El Dorado Springs, MO Opera House 2 days subrun
Thu 23 Jun 1927 White River Junction, VT Lyric Theatre 1 day subrun
Thu 23 Jun 1927 Franklin, PA Park 2 days subrun
Thu 23 Jun 1927 Philadelphia, PA Broadway 3 days third run
Thu 23 Jun 1927 Baltimore, MD Walbrook 1 day third run
Fri 24 Jun 1927 Barre, VT Park 2 days subrun
Fri 24 Jun 1927 Caldwell, ID American Theatre 2 day subrun
Fri 24 Jun 1927 Kennewick, WA Liberty Theatre 2 days subrun
Sat 25 Jun 1927 Washington, DC York Theatre 1 day second run
Sat 25 Jun 1927 Washington, DC Chevy Chase Theatre 1 day second run
Sun 26 Jun 1927 Washington, DC Crandall’s Colony Theatre 2 days second run
Sun 26 Jun 1927 Cincinnati, OH Walnut 7 days locomotive sex appeal, locomotive sex appeal
Sun 26 Jun 1927 Chilton, WI Princess Theatre 2 days  
Mon 27 Jun 1927 Connellsville, PA Arcade Theatre 3 days subrun
Mon 27 Jun 1927 Atlanta, GA Ponce de Leon Theatre 2 days second run
Mon 27 Jun 1927 Evansville, IN American 7 days subrun
Tue 28 Jun 1927 Flagstaff, AZ Orpheum 1 show benefit
Thu 30 Jun 1927 Harrisburg, PA Russell 1 day subrun
Thu 30 Jun 1927 Hilo, HI Empire 3 days  
Fri 01 Jul 1927 Derry, PA Gem Theatre 1 day subrun
Fri 01 Jul 1927 Frederick, MD Tivoli (Stanley-Crandall) 1 day subrun
Fri 01 Jul 1927 Ashland, AL Ingram’s Theatre 1 day  
Fri 01 Jul 1927 Minneapolis, MN Lagoon 2 days second run
Sat 02 Jul 1927 Allentown, PA Lotus 1 day second run
Sat 02 Jul 1927 Washington, DC Carolina Theatre 1 day second run
Sun 03 Jul 1927 Upper Darby, PA 69th Street Theatre 4 days subrun
Sun 03 Jul 1927 Sayre, OK Princess 2 days subrun
Mon 04 Jul 1927 St. Johnsbury, VT Tegu’s Palace Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 04 Jul 1927 Ogdensburg, NY Strand Theatre 2 days subrun
Mon 04 Jul 1927 Philadelphia, PA Ambassador 3 days third run
Mon 04 Jul 1927 Sedalia, MO Sedalia Theatre 2 days subrun
Mon 04 Jul 1927 Wilburton, OK American Theatre 2 days subrun
Tue 05 Jul 1927 Tampa, FL Strand Theatre 3 days  
Wed 06 Jul 1927 Hilo, HI Empire 1 more encore
Fri 08 Jul 1927 Biddeford, ME City Theater 2 days subrun
Sat 02 Jul 1927 New Orleans, LA Prytania 1 day second run
Fri 08 Jul 1927 New Orleans, LA Washington 1 day second run
Mon 11 Jul 1927 Bristol, PA Riverside 2 days subrun
Mon 11 Jul 1927 Lansdowne Borough, PA Lansdowne 2 days subrun
Tue 12 Jul 1927 Benton Harbor, MI Liberty Theatre 2 days subrun
Tue 12 Jul 1927 Oklahoma City, OK Folly Theatre 2 days second run
Wed 13 Jul 1927 Knoxville, TN Green Theatre 2 days second run
Thu 14 Jul 1927 Portland, ME Loew’s Portland 2 days second run
Fri 15 Jul 1927 Huntington, NY Palace Theatre 1 day subrun
Thu 15 Jul 1927 New Orleans, LA Capitol 1 day second run
Fri 16 Jul 1927 New Orleans, LA Tivoli 1 day second run
Fri 15 Jul 1927 Auckland, NZ Strand 5 days? doubled with Valencia
Sat 16 Jul 1927 New Orleans, LA Fine Arts 1 day second run
Sun 17 Jul 1927 Honolulu, HI Kaimuki 2 days  
Mon 18 Jul 1927 Waterbury, VT Rialto Theatre 2 days subrun
Mon 18 Jul 1927 Tunkhannock, PA Savoy 1 day subrun
Mon 18 Jul 1927 Okemah, OK Crystal 2 days subrun
Wed 20 Jul 1927 Greenville, SC Carolina Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 21 Jul 1927 Marshfield, WI Adler Theatre 3 days subrun
Fri 22 Jul 1927 Miami, FL Fotosho 1 day third run
Fri 22 Jul 1927 New Orleans, LA Carrollton 1 day second run
Fri 22 Jul 1927 Provo, UT Paramount Theatre 2 days subrun
Sat 23 Jul 1927 Selma, AL Academy 1 day subrun
Sat 23 Jul 1927 New Orleans, LA Escorial 1 day second run
Sun 24 Jul 1927 Honolulu, HI Kaimuki 2 days encore
Sun 24 Jul 1927 Philadelphia, PA Leader 4 days third run
Tue 26 Jul 1927 Auburn, NY Strand 2 days subrun, PR
Wed 27 Jul 1927 Manchester, VT Arcade Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 28 Jul 1927 New Britain, CT Lyceum 3 days 2nd to Wandering Footsteps
Thu 28 Jul 1927 Haskell, OK Orpheum 2 days subrun
Thu 28 Jul 1927 Fort Collins, CO America Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 29 Jul 1927 Adair, OK Joy Theatre 2 days subrun
Sat 30 Jul 1927 Milton, PA Legionaire 1 day subrun
Sat 30 Jul 1927 New Orleans, LA Granada 1 day second run
Sat 30 Jul 1927 Denver, CO Washington Park 1 day second run
Sun 31 Jul 1927 Tampa, FL Seminole Theatre 1 day second run
Sun 31 Jul 1927 Fort Lauderdale, FL Garden Court Theatre
404 Las Olas Blvd
1 night subrun
Sun 31 Jul 1927 Battle Creek, MI Bijou Arcade Theater 4 days  
Sun 31 Jul 1927 Port Huron, MI Desmond Theatre 4 days  
Sun 31 Jul 1927 Madison, WI Orpheum 4 days  
Mon 01 Aug 1927 Massena, NY Strand 2 days subrun
Wed 03 Aug 1927 Burlington, VT Majestic 2 days subrun
Wed 03 Aug 1927 Cobleskill, NY Park Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 05 Aug 1927 St. Louis, MO Knickerbocker 1 day third run
Tue 06 Aug 1927 Amsterdam, NL Edison ????? doubled with Battling Butler
Sat 06 Aug 1927 Colton, CA Colton Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 08 Aug 1927 Gardiner, ME Johnson Opera House 1 day subrun
Mon 08 Aug 1927 Rock Hill, SC Omar 2 days subrun
Thu 11 Aug 1927 Shamokin, PA Victoria 2 days subrun
Thu 11 Aug 1927 Nashville, TN Hillsboro 3 days second run
Thu 11 Aug 1927 Lead, SD Homestake Opera House 2 days subrun
Sun 14 Aug 1927 Brownsville, TX Dittman 3 days subrun
Sun 14 Aug 1927 Bismarck, ND Eltinge Theater 2 days subrun
Mon 15 Aug 1927 Smyrna, DE Dover Opera House 2 days subrun
Mon 15 Aug 1927 Little Rock, AR Gem Theatre 3 days second run
Mon 15 Aug 1927 Whakatane, NZ Town Hall 2 days subrun
Tue 16 Aug 1971 Ogden, UT Colonial 2 days second run
Sat 20 Aug 1971 Warren, PA Library Theatre (Columbia Amsmt) 1 day second run
Sat 20 Aug 1927 New Orleans, LA Mecca 1 day second run
Sun 21 Aug 1927 Muskegon, MI Rialto 4 days  
Mon 22 Aug 1927 Vancouver, BC Colonial 6 days  
Tue 23 Aug 1927 Wisconsin Rapids, WI Palace 2 days subrun
Thu 25 Aug 1927 Carlisle, PA Orpheum 2 days subrun
Thu 25 Aug 1927 Muskegon Heights, MI Strand 1 day second run
Fri 26 Aug 1971 Salt Lake, UT Rialto 2 days second run
Sat 27 Aug 1927 Lamont, OK Cozy Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 29 Aug 1927 Madera, CA National Theatre 2 days subrun
Sun 28 Aug 1927 Angola, NY Angola Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 02 Sep 1927 Portland, ME Colonial 2 days (replaced by Battling Butler)
Fri 02 Sep 1927 Springfield, VT Ideal Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 02 Sep 1927 Hazleton, PA Capitol 2 days subrun
Sat 03 Sep 1927 Newport, VT Burns Theatre 1 day subrun
Sat 03 Sep 1927 Tarrytown, NY Music Hall Theatre 1 day subrun
Sun 04 Sep 1927 Erie, PA Rialto 4 days subrun
Sun 04 Sep 1927 Saxon, WI Royal Theatre 2 days subrun
Mon 12 Sep 1927 Davis, OK Strand Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 15 Sep 1927 Craig, MO Wickiser Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 19 Sep 1927 Mount Carmel, PA Victoria 2 days subrun
Wed 21 Sep 1927 Latrobe, PA Olympic Theatre 2 days doubled with Altars of Desire
Thu 22 Sep 1927 Fairport, NY New Temple Theatre 2 days  
Fri 23 Sep 1927 Pittsfield, MA Tyler 2 days second run
Sun 25 Sep 1927 Lansing, MI Strand Theatre 4 days  
Mon 26 Sep 1927 Green Bay, WI Orpheum 4 days  
Thu 29 Sep 1927 Stevens Point, WI Majestic 3 days  
Tue 27 Sep 1927 Deadwood, SD Deadwood Theatre 1 day subrun
Thu 29 Sep 1927 Pulaski, NY Temple Theatre 2 days  
Thu 29 Sep 1927 Union Springs, AL Rialto Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 30 Sep 1927 Durant, OK Queen (R and R) 2 days subrun
Sat 01 Oct 1927 Rockville Centre, NY Strand 1 day subrun
Mon 03 Oct 1927 Elizabeth City, NC Alkrama 2 days subrun
Tue 04 Oct 1927 Fairlee, VT Star Theatre 1 day subrun
Thu 06 Oct 1927 Florence, SC Opera House 1 day subrun
Fri 07 Oct 1927 Manitowoc, WI Mikadow 2 days subrun
Sun 09 Oct 1927 Elmira, NY Capitol Theatre 4 days subrun
Tue 11 Oct 1927 Kansas City, MO Westport 1 day third run
Thu 13 Oct 1927 Raleigh, NC State 2 days subrun
Fri 14 Oct 1927 Penn Yan, NY Elmwood Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 14 Oct 1927 Greenville, SC Egyptian 1 day second run
Sat 15 Oct 1927 Allentown, PA Southern Theatre 1 day third run
ca 15 Oct 1927 Carmel, CA Manzanita Theatre 1 day subrun
Sun 16 Oct 1927 Mason, MI Pastime Theatre 2 days subrun
Mon 17 Oct 1927 Scranton, PA Capitol 3 days subrun
Thu 13 Oct 1927 Raleigh, NC Palace 1 day moveover
Mon 17 Oct 1927 Coventry, Eng. La Scala 7 days  
Thu 20 Oct 1927 Waco, TX Victory 3 days second run
Some Opinions from Smaller Markets:
Fri 21 Oct 1927 West Hampton Beach, NY Hampton Star Theatre 2 days subrun
Sat 22 Oct 1927 Chillicothe, MO Strand 1 day subrun
Sun 23 Oct 1927 Tooele, UT Strand Theatre 2 days subrun
ca Mon 24 Oct 1927 Vienna, Austria Kino Wienzeite ?????  
ca Mon 24 Oct 1927 Wilkes-Barre, PA Capitol 3 days subrun
ca Mon 24 Oct 1927 Gretna, LA Hollywood 1 day second run
ca Thu 25 Oct 1927 Vienna, Austria Zirkus Busch-Kino ?????  
Thu 27 Oct 1927 Rutland, VT Ludlow Theatre 1 day second run
Thu 27 Oct 1927 Brownsville, TX Texas (Delta) 2 days second run
Fri 28 Oct 1927 Franklin, PA Venango Theatre (Delta) 2 days second run
Sat 29 Oct 1927 Diller, NE Diller Opera House 1 night subrun
Mon 31 Oct 1927 Tuscumbia, AL Strand 1 day subrun
Tue 01 Nov 1927 Sheffield, AL Palace 1 day subrun
Thu 03 Nov 1927 Florence, AL Princess 1 day subrun
Thu 03 Nov 1927 Burnaby, BC Regent 2 days second run
Thu 03 Nov 1927 Clarence, MO Culver Theatre 2 days second run
Wed 09 Nov 1927 Custer City, OK Rex Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 10 Nov 1927 Newark, NY Capitol 2 days subrun
Thu 10 Nov 1927 Olean, NY Haven Theatre 3 days subrun
Thu 10 Nov 1927 Bartlesville, OK Odeon 1 day second run
Thu 10 Nov 1927 Covina, CA Covina Theatre 1 day subrun
Fri 11 Nov 1927 Palmyra, NY Park 2 days subrun
Mon 14 Nov 1927 Poteau, OK Victory 2 days subrun
Thu 17 Nov 1927 Kansas City, MO Indiana 1 day third run
Wed 23 Nov 1927 Kansas City, MO Aladdin 1 day 2nd to Slide, Kelly, Slide
Sat 26 Nov 1927 San Francisco, CA Imperial 7 days  
Sun 27 Nov 1927 South Miami, FL Riviera Theatre 1 day subrun
Tue 30 Nov 1927 Springfield, MO Princess Theatre 2 days subrun
ca 01 Dec 1927 Paris, AR Strand Theatre ????? subrun
Mon 05 Dec 1927 Gaffney, SC Strand Theatre 2 days  
Thu 08 Dec 1927 Cooperstown, NY Smalley’s Cooperstown Theatre 1 day subrun
Fri 09 Dec 1927? Doetinchem, NL Luxor Theater 7 days  
Tue 13 Dec 1927 Oklahoma City, OK Rialto 2 days second run
Wed 14 Dec 1927 Rising Sun, MD Rising Sun Moving Picture House 1 day subrun
Wed 14 Dec 1927 Kilmarnock, VA Fairfax Theatre 1 day subrun
Thu 15 Dec 1927 Antlers, OK Erie Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 16 Dec 1927 Berwick, PA Strand 2 days subrun
Fri 17 Dec 1927 Akron, OH Orpheum 7 days  
Tue 20 Dec 1927 Austin, TX Crescent 3 days second run
Wed 21 Dec 1927 Binghamton, NY Capitol Theatre 1 day 2nd bill after Lonesome Ladies
Fri 23 Dec 1927 Boston, MA Boys’ Club 1 show special
Fri 23 Dec 1927 Mexico, MO Liberty Theatre 1 day third run
Sun 25 Dec 1927 Syracuse, NY Swan (formerly Happy Hour), 224 N Salina St 1 day second run
Mon 26 Dec 1927 Gloucester, Eng. Parkend Empire 3 days subrun
Mon 26 Dec 1927 Coplay, PA Pastime 1 day subrun
Tue 27 Dec 1927 Sleepy Hollow, NY Strand Theatre 1 day subrun
ca 30 Dec 1927 Stapleton, NE Paramount Theatre ????? subrun
Sat 31 Dec 1927 Oakland, CA Grand Lake 7 days  
Sun 01 Jan 1928 Minneapolis, MN New Arion 1 day third run
Mon 02 Jan 1928 Redwood City, CA Sequoia Theatre 2 days subrun, press release, crowds
Tue 03 Jan 1928 Butte, MT Ansonia 2 days subrun
Fri 06 Jan 1928 Kansas City, MO Diamond 1 day third run
Fri 06 Jan 1928 Burlingame, CA Varsity 2 days second run
Tue 10 Jan 1928 Griswold, IA Strand Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 12 Jan 1928 Oshkosh, WI Rex 3 days subrun
Thu 12 Jan 1928 Endicott, NY Lyric 3 days subrun
Sat 14 Jan 1928 Hinton, WV Masonic 1 day subrun
Sat 14 Jan 1928 Sacramento, CA Capitol 4 days  
Mon 16 Jan 1928 Widnes, Cheshire Century Picture Palace 3 days subrun
Tue 17 Jan 1928 Endicott, NY Elvin 1 day subrun
Thu 19 Jan 1928 Napa, CA Hippodrome Theatre 2 days second bill to Partners Again
ca 20 Jan 1928 Lewellyn, NE Hipp Theatre ????? subrun
Fri 20 Jan 1928 Ardmore, OK Ritz 2 days subrun
Sat 21 Jan 1928 Minette, AL Palm Theatre 1 day subrun
Sat 21 Jan 1928 Mullen, NE Senk Theatre 1 day subrun
Sat 21 Jan 1928 Fresno, CA Wilson 3 days subrun
Sat 21 Jan 1928 Wood River, IL Wood River Theater 1 day subrun
Sun 22 Jan 1928 Salinas, CA California Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 23 Jan 1928 Calgary, AB Variety 3 days subrun
Wed 25 Jan 1928 Stockton, CA State (Fox) 3 days subrun
Fri 27 Jan 1928 Alton, IL Gem 1 day subrun
Sun 29 Jan 1928 Columbus, NE Pawnee 3 days subrun
Tue 31 Jan 1928 Sioux City, IA Strand 3 days second feature to Poor Girls
ca 01 Feb 1928 Crosby, MN People’s Theatre ????? subrun
Wed 01 Feb 1928 Syracuse, NE Palace 1 day subrun
Wed 01 Feb 1928 Colusa, CA Gem 2 days subrun
Thu 02 Feb 1928 Unadilla, NE Palace Theatre 1 day subrun, with King Felton magic show
Thu 02 Feb 1928 Oroville, CA Rex 1 day subrun
Fri 03 Feb 1928 Culver, IN Home Theatre 2 days subrun
Sat 043 Feb 1928 Saline, MI Liberty Theatre 2 days subrun
ca 05 Feb 1928 Buena Vista, VA Globe Theatre ????? subrun
Sun 05 Feb 1928 Sidney, NE U. S. A. Theatre 1 day subrun
Wed 08 Feb 1928 Burlington, VT Orpheum Theatre 2 days second run
Wed 08 Feb 1928 Lowville, NY Bijou 1 day subrun, PR
Wed 08 Feb 1928 Hanford, CA Royal Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 10 Feb 1928 Emporia, KS Odeon 2 days subrun
Fri 10 Feb 1928 Oakland, CA Chimes 2 days subrun
Sun 12 Feb 1928 Brooklyn, NY Imperial 1 day third run
Sun 12 Feb 1928 Williams, AZ Sultana 1 day subrun
Wed 15 Feb 1928 Salamanca, NY Andrews Theatre 1 day subrun, PR
Wed 15 Feb 1928 Riverton, NE New Theatre 1 day subrun
Sat 18 Feb 1928 Freeland, PA Refowich Theatre 1 day subrun
Fri 24 Feb 1928 Monongahela, PA Anton 2 days subrun
Wed 29 Feb 1928 Reno, NV Reno 2 days subrun
Mon 05 Mar 1928 Belleville, IL Rex Theater 2 days subrun, PR
Tue 06 Mar 1928 Kenosha, WI Roosevelt 1 day second run, PR
Wed 07 Mar 1928 Halifax, NS Community Theatre 2 days subrun, PR
Wed 07 Mar 1928 Boise, ID Rialto 2 days subrun, PR
Thu 08 Mar 1928 Derby, Derbys, Eng. Normanton 3 days subrun
Thu 08 Mar 1928 Iola, KS Elite 2 days subrun
Fri 09 Mar 1928 Albuquerque, NM Pastime Theatre (Indep.) 2 days subrun
Fri 09 Mar 1928 San Francisco, CA Alexandria 2 days third run, PR
Wed 14 Mar 1928 Winnipeg, MB Rose (Allied) 2 days subrun
Sun 11 Mar 1928 Vancouver, BC Globe Theatre 4 days subrun, 2nd after For Wives Only
Mon 12 Mar 1928 Togus, ME National Home for Disabled Volunteer Soldiers 1 day special
Tue 13 Mar 1928 Kenosha, WI Butterfly 3 days subrun
Mon 19 Mar 1928 Oshkosh, WI Star 2 days subrun
Thu 22 Mar 1928 Rutland, VT Brandon Theater 1 day second run
Thu 22 Mar 1928 Selma, CA Selma Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 22 Mar 1928 Winnipeg, MB Plaza 1 day subrun
Fri 23 Mar 1928 Shelby, NE Shelby Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 23 Mar 1928 Stanton, NE Rialto 1 day subrun
Sat 24 Mar 1928 Deming, NM Princess Theatre 1 day subrun
Sun 25 Mar 1928 Kimball, SD Royal Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 26 Mar 1928 Weeping Water, NE Liberty Theatre 2 days subrun, PR
Tue 27 Mar 1928 Ironwood, MI Ramsay Rex 2 days subrun
Wed 28 Mar 1928 Bloomfield, NE ★ Theater 2 days subrun
Fri 30 Mar 1928 Aurora, NE Mazda 2 days subrun
Sat 31 Mar 1928 Binghamton, NY Empire Theatre 1 day second run
Sun 02 Apr 1928 Decatur, NE Goldlight 1 night subrun
Mon 03 Apr 1928 Tampa, FL Grand Theater 1 day second run
Thu 05 Apr 1928 Winnipeg, MB Garden 2 days subrun
Mon 09 Apr 1928 Uphall, Scotland Cinema House 3 days subrun
Wed 11 Apr 1928 Corpus Christi, TX Melba Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 12 Apr 1928 Edenbridge, Kent, Eng. Edenbridge Cinema 3 days subrun
Thu 12 Apr 1928 Quincy, CA Quincy Theatre? 1 day subrun
Thu 12 Apr 1928 Oakland, CA Broadway 2 days third run, in conjunction with Pendleton Roundup
Sat 14 Apr 1928 Sacramento, CA California Theatre 1 day second run
Sun 15 Apr 1928 Oakland, CA Century 2 days third run, doubled with West of Broadway
Mon 16 Apr 1928 Bellingham, WA Grand 1 day subrun
Tue 24 Apr 1928 East Moline, IL Strand 2 days subrun
Thu 26 Apr 1928 Macon, GA Rialto 1 show special
May 1928 Translatlantic S.S. Columbus ????? special
Sat 05 May 1928 Miami, FL Tivoli 1 day third run
Wed 09 May 1928 Norman, OK Billings 2 days second run
Thu 10 May 1928 Brownsville, TX Texas (Delta) 2 days second run
Tue 15 May 1928 Plattsburg, MO Opera House 1 day? subrun
Tue 15 May 1928 Marysville, CA Liberty 2 days subrun
Fri 18 May 1928 Rutherford, NJ Rivoli 2 days 2nd billed to The Love of Sunya
Sat 19 May 1928 Stockton, CA Rialto Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 21 May 1928 Columbus, IN Crump 2 days subrun
Tue 22 May 1928 Circleville, OH Grand 2 days subrun
Wed 30 May 1928 Miami, FL Seventh Avenue 2 days third run, PR
Wed 30 May 1928 Council Grove, KS Stella Theatre 1 day subrun, PR
Thu 31 May 1928 Venice, CA California Theatre (West Coast) 1 day 2nd billed to Hell Ship Bronson
Thu 31 May 1928 San Francisco, CA Casino 2 days double billed with The 13th Juror
Sun 03 Jun 1928 Grand Junction, CO Majestic Theatre 3 days subrun, PR
Sun 03 Jun 1928 Modesto, CA Lyric Theatre 2 days subrun
Sat 09 Jun 1928 Groton, VT Henderson Theatre 1 day subrun
Thu 14 Jun 1928 Franklin, KY Victor Theatre 1 day subrun
Fri 15 Jun 1928 Marksville, LA Bailey Theatre 1 day subrun
Sat 16 Jun 1928 Groton, VT Henderson Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 18 Jun 1928 Hayward, CA Hayward Theatre 1 day subrun
Thu 21 Jun 1928 Sevenoaks, Eng. Tubs Hill Cinema 3 days third run
Sat 23 Jun 1928 Springville, UT Rivoli Theatre 1 day subrun
Thu 28 Jun 1928 Chester, Chesh, Eng. Music Hall “THE” Cinema 3 days subrun
Fri 29 Jun 1928 Trenton, NE Gem Theatre 2 days subrun
Fri 29 Jun 1928 Corpus Christi, TX Ideal (R.&R.) 1 day third run
Mon 02 Jul 1928 Natchitoches, LA Amusu Theatre 1 day subrun
Wed 04 Jul 1928 Mexico, NY Town Hall Movies 1 day subrun
Wed 04 Jul 1928 Mayfield, CA Blanco’s California Theatre 1 day doubled with The Wagon Show
Sun 15 Jul 1928 Minneapolis, MN Bijou 1 day third run
Mon 16 Jul 1928 Tampa, FL Alcazar 2 days subrun
Mon 16 Jul 1928 Portsmouth, OH LaRoy 3 days? subrun
Tue 24 Jul 1928 Boston, MA Lancaster 1 day subrun
Thu 26 Jul 1928 St. Joseph, MO Empress Theatre 1 day subrun
Sat 28 Jul 1928 St. Joseph, MO Rivoli 1 day subrun
Mon 30 Jul 1928 Beatrice, NE Ritz Theatre 2 days benefit, PR
Tue 31 Jul 1928 Omaha, NE Minne Lusa (Neighborhood) 1 day subrun
Wed 01 Aug 1928 Liverpool, Eng. Casino 1 day repertory
Thu 02 Aug 1928 Maryville, MO College Auditorium 2 days special
Tue 07 Aug 1928 Ealing, London, Eng. Walpole Cinema 1 day subrun
Tue 07 Aug 1928 Madisonville, KY New Kentucky Theatre 1 day subrun
Tue 14 Aug 1928 Bradford, VT Colonial 1 day subrun
Mon 13 Aug 1928 Marion, OH Oakland 3 days subrun
Sat 18 Aug 1928 Racine, WI Crown Theatre 1 day second run
Thu 23 Aug 1928 Greenville, MI Silver Family Theatre 1 day subrun
Mon 27 Aug 1928 Woodward, OK Pastime 2 days subrun
Fri 31 Aug 1928 Winnipeg, MB Bijou 2 days 2nd billed to Tillie’s Punctured Romance
Fri 14 Sep 1928 Durham, NC Savoy 1 day subrun
Mon 24 Sep 1928 Covington, KY Shirley 1 day subrun
Mon 24 Sep 1928 Paducah, KY Loop 4 days subrun, PR, PR, PR
Mon 24 Sep 1928 Visalia, CA Bijou 1 day subrun
Thu 27 Sep 1928 Derby, Derbys, Eng. Cosy 1 day subrun, PR
Fri 28 Sep 1928 Covington, KY Family 1 day subrun
Fri 05 Oct 1928 Bethany, NE Sun 2 days subrun
Mon 08 Oct 1928 Painted Post, NY Imperial, IOOF, S Hamilton St 2 days subrun
Fri 12 Oct 1928 Lincoln, NE Legion 2 days subrun
Sat 13 Oct 1928 Tekamah, NE Lyric Theatre 1 day subrun
Sat 13 Oct 1928 Fort Worth, TX Worth Theatre midnight benefit
Wed 24 Oct 1928 San António, TX Rialto 3 days? Unconfirmed. Originally booked for the Aztec, but never played. The Rialto did not advertise this show.
Fri 09 Nov 1928 Chester, Ches, Eng. Village Institute for Llay 1 show special, doubled with The Country Doctor
Sat 10 Nov 1928 Lancaster, PA Hamilton Theatre 1 show D.A.R. children’s matinée, PR
Sat 10 Nov 1928 Washington, DC Takoma 1 day doubled with The Leopard Lady
Mon 26 Nov 1928 Saffron Walden, Eng. Cinema 1 day subrun
Thu 29 Nov 1928 Bassett, NE Bassett Auditorium 1 day subrun
Fri 30 Nov 1928 Stuart, NE Gem Theatre 1 day subrun
Sat 01 Dec 1928 Bassett, NE Bassett Auditorium 1 day subrun
Mon 03 Dec 1928 Coventry, Eng. Rialto 3 days subrun, PR
Tue 04 Dec 1928 Vancouver, WA Society Theatre 2 days second run
Wed 05 Dec 1928 Hartford, CT State 2 days 2nd after Three Ring Marriage, PR
Thu 06 Dec 1928 Bristow, NE Bristow Theatre 3 days subrun
Thu 06 Dec 1928 Reedley, CA Star Theatre 2 days subrun
Mon 10 Dec 1928 Claresholm, AB Rex Theatre 2 days second run
Mon 24 Dec 1928 McKinney, TX Pope (R.&R.) 2 days subrun
Thu 27 Dec 1928 Santa Rosa, CA Rose Theatre 2 days second run
Tue 01 Jan 1929 Dayton, OH YMCA Auditorium 1 show special
Tue 01 Jan 1929 Alton, IL Princess 1 day subrun
Thu 03 Jan 1929 Portland, ME E.M. Loew’s Casco 1 day subrun
Wed 09 Jan 1929 Muskegon, MI Iris 1 day third run
Fri 01 Feb 1929 Hamburg, NY Palace Theatre 2 days subrun; doubled with Driftin’ Sands
Mon 04 Feb 1929 Clarksville, TN Capitol Theatre 2 days subrun
Thu 07 Feb 1929 Juneau, AK Coliseum 2 days subrun
Sun 10 Feb 1929 Juneau, AK Liberty 1 day subrun
Fri 15 Feb 1929 St. Petersburg, FL Cameo 2 days subrun
Fri 08 Mar 1929 Frome, Somerset Frome’s New Cinema 2 days crowded houses are assured
Mon 01 Apr 1929 Orlando, FL Grand 2 days press release
Sat 13 Apr 1929 Landisburg, PA Shadowland Theatre 1 show subrun
Sat 13 Apr 1929 Seward, AK Liberty 3 days subrun, PR
Fri 19 Apr 1929 Geneva, NE Sunbeam 2 days subrun
Sat 20 Apr 1929 Menasha, WI Orpheum (Fox-Midwesco) 1 day subrun
Sat 27 Apr 1929 Elizabethtown, PA Moose Theatre 1 day subrun
ca 01 May 1929 Tombstone, AZ Crystal Theatre ????? subrun
Thu 02 May 1929 Crete, NE Lyric Theatre 2 days subrun
Sat 04 May 1929 Orlando, FL Civic Auditorium 1 day press release
Sun 05 May 1929 Farwell, NE Sun Theatre 1 day subrun
There are so many comments like this,
that I at last decided to include one representative example:

So there ya go! Too pricey and rude personnel. Not a good combo.
Thu 09 May 1929 Claresholm, AB Rex Theatre 3 days subrun, press release
Thu 09 May 1929 Bell, CA Fox Alcazar 1 day revival
Mon 20 May 1929 Retford, Eng. Regent 7 days?  
Tue 21 May 1929 St. Petersburg, FL Cameo 2 days 2nd feature after Wild Orchids
Sat 25 May 1929 Fogelsville, PA Lehigh Community Park & Playgrounds 1 day nontheatrical condensed edition
Sat 29 Jun 1929 Pasadena, CA Park 1 day revival
Wed 11 Sep 1929 Camden, SC Majestic 2 days subrun
Fri 01 Nov 1929 York, NE Dean 2 days subrun
Mon 18 Nov 1929 Lancaster, PA Martin Auditorium, YMCA 1 show nontheatrical condensed edition
Sat 25 Jan 1930 Ridgewood, NJ Play House 1 show children’s matinée
Wed 19 Feb 1930 Rahway, NJ Empire Theatre 1 show presented by Raritan Preps Jr. A.C.
Sun 27 Apr 1930 London, Eng. Coronet, Notting Hill Gate 1 night doubled with Son of the Sheik
Sat 19 Apr 1930 Chippewa Falls, WI Northern Wisconsin Colony and Training School 2 shows nontheatrical condensed edition
Mon 28 Apr 1930 Uxbridge, Eng. Savoy 1 day 2nd after The Hottentot
Fri 30 May 1930 Heflin, AL Community Theatre 2 days subrun
Sat 07 Jun 1930 Hartford, CT Broadway Community Church 1 show nontheatrical condensed edition
Sun 22 Jun 1930 Springfield, OH Majestic 2 days 2nd bill after Two Arabian Nights
Mon 07 Jul 1930 Croydon, London, Eng. Albany 6 days doubled with The College Coquette
Mon 28 Jul 1930 Croydon, London, Eng. Empire 3 days second run
Tue 12 Aug 1930 Big Bear Lake, CA Stillwell Country Club Theatre 2 days nontheatrical condensed edition
Thu 11 Sep 1930 Dover, Kent, Eng. Queen’s Hall 3 days subrun
Sat 27 Sep 1930 Lincoln, NE Stuart Theatre 1 show children’s matinée
Thu 23 Oct 1930 Hammersmith, London, Eng. Fulham Picture Palace 4 days doubled with Seven Faces
Mon 15 Dec 1930 Acton, London, Eng. Crown 7 days 2nd bill to Love Comes Along
Sun 11 Jan 1931 Fort Thomas, KY Hiland 2 days 2nd bill to Doughboys
Thu 15 Jan 1931 Herts, Eng. Sawbridgeworth Cinema 3 days third run
Mon 26 Jan 1931 Bath, Eng. Assembly Rooms 3 days 2nd bill to Sarah and Son
Mon 09 Feb 1931 Derby, Derbys, Eng. Cosmo Cinema 3 days 2nd bill to The Three Kings, PR
Thu 12 Feb 1931 Dover, Eng. Plaza Super Cinema 3 days 2nd bill to Sisters
Mon 23 Feb 1931 Croydon, London, Eng. Gaiety 3 days 2nd bill to The Bad One
Thu 25 Feb 1931 Derby, Derbys, Eng. Cosmo 3 days doubled with Darling of Paris
Mon 15 Jun 1931 Hammersmith, London, Eng. Forum Theatre 3 days 2nd bill to Birds of Prey
And that, I think, was it, until MoMA began exhibiting the film probably in the mid-1930’s,
and circulating the film beginning probably in 1941 or maybe in 1942.

You noticed that several of the above listings were for the “nontheatrical condensed edition.” What does that mean? David Shepard, through his Film Preservation Associates, issued a VHS in 1998 called “Here Comes the General.” It consisted of three short subjects: Return of the General, a 1962 commemorative; Railroad Raiders of ’62, the surviving fragment of the 1911 Kalem telling of the tale; and The General, an abridgment. On the back cover, David explained: “The original producer prepared this intelligently abridged version for non-theatrical showing in the late 1920s, and we restored a few additional scenes too good to omit! It retains all the wonderful scenes of the locomotive chase, de-emphasizing only portions of the story which do not involve the trains.” The tape, unfortunately, did not include a transfer of the 16mm original, but simply edited a 35mm transfer to match. I need to study the original.

Movie historians, though, are concerned with none of the regular bookings. They are concerned only with the Manhattan opening. Why? I don’t know. But that’s all they care about. Meade, as far as I know, was the first to state that The General was originally scheduled for an “end of December” 1926 opening at Loew’s Capitol. Actually, as we witnessed above, it had been scheduled for an opening on New Year’s Day, 1927. That opening was delayed twice over, first to Saturday, 22 January 1927, and then to Saturday, 5 February. It played the usual one week at the Capitol, then it disappeared from NYC screens for a week, and then it was back, briefly, at a few neighborhood houses, and then it was gone. This was the standard pattern for a successful movie. An unsuccessful movie would not be likely to reappear after the downtown booking.

Much more to study, and I don’t think I’ll put much more of this info on this page. I’ll reserve that for a future project. In the meantime, my preliminary impressions are simple: The General did respectable business in urban markets. The rental price was probably considerably less than $10,000, but it was nonetheless too high, or so it seems, which cut into a cinema’s profits during first-run bookings. Curtis (p. 319) provided a single example: The Metropolitan in Los Ángeles, the largest cinema in the city, received The General for one week for a flat $5,000 rental. That sounds strange to me. Awfully strange. First-run deluxe bookings are rental versus percentage. Am I wrong about that? Flat rental is financial suicide for the investors. Yet Jim got that info from Variety, and so I suppose the report is correct, and that was a great deal for the Metropolitan, but why UA agreed is anybody’s guess. My guess is that someone’s head rolled within the week. Some of the ticket sales were considered relatively low, but, in some cases, relatively low was still profitable. For instance, Loew’s Capitol in Manhattan, NY, had a seemingly unimpressive ticket sales of $50,992, but that was the high end of normal for the Capitol, and, with a single exception, it was much higher than ticket sales for other cinemas in the area. That indicates something like over 60,000 tickets sold during the week, which I don’t think is so awful. Do you? Curtis (p. 319) reports that the Metropolitan in Los Ángeles had a “disappointing” gross of $25,000. Variety gave an estimate of $25,300. Tickets at the Metropolitan were 25¢ and 65¢, and so, if “gross” means “ticket sales” (does it?), $25,300 would indicate probably in the range of 56,000 tickets sold that week, give or take, or about 8,000 tickets a day, for an auditorium that sat about 3,600 people. Yes, the house had better weeks and it had worse weeks, and while $25,300 was not extraordinary for the Metropolitan, it was well within normal range. Besides, 56,000 sales in a week ain’t too bad no matter how you cut it. I just did a tiny bit of exploring. Here are some Variety reports for the Metropolitan:

VARIETY TICKET SALES
Vol. 85 No. 12, Wed 05 Jan 1927, p. 6, The Canadian $26,500
Vol. 85 No. 13, Wed 12 Jan 1927, p. 6, Blonde or Brunette $31,000
Vol. 86 No. 01, Wed 19 Jan 1927, p. 7, Man of the Forest $25,000
Vol. 86 No. 02, Wed 26 Jan 1927, p. 8, It $35,000
Vol. 86 No. 03, Wed 02 Feb 1927, p. 6, New York $38,000
Vol. 86 No. 04, Wed 09 Feb 1927, p. 6, Paradise for Two $32,000
Vol. 86 No. 05, Wed 16 Feb 1927, p. 6, Hotel Imperial $30,000
Vol. 86 No. 06, Wed 23 Feb 1927, p. 6, Let It Rain $23,000
Vol. 86 No. 07, Wed 02 Mar 1927, p. 6, Love’s Greatest Mistake $25,000
Vol. 86 No. 08, Wed 09 Mar 1927, p. 6, A Kiss in a Taxi $22,000
Vol. 86 No. 09, Wed 16 Mar 1927, p. 7, Evening Clothes $27,500
Vol. 86 No. 10, Wed 23 Mar 1927, p. 6, The General $25,300


You see? It’s within the average range, and the average range was pretty darned good.

Localities with direct interest — Oregon, Tennessee, Georgia — did exceptional business for the first three days or so. I have not included reports from cow country, as that would take too long and would be too tedious. Nonetheless, I can conclude that, with but rare exceptions, cow country just didn’t like Buster at all and kept away. Buster’s features played to nearly empty cow-country houses and garnered gripes from irritated cow-country patrons. Cinema owners and managers in cow country hated it when Buster flicks landed on their doorsteps, because they knew they would go into deficit. Only a few reviews were negative, and the negative reviews voiced mostly one of two objections: It was not a laff riot; or, it was a travesty of the true Andrews Raid and would lead to children having a malformed concept of US history. Some of the positive reviews were tempered by a disappointment that the movie was not a laff riot. I also get the impression, the vague impression, that some cinemas simply gave poor presentations, and that those poor presentations almost exactly correlated with poor reviews and poor box office. Perhaps they provided inappropriate music, which can kill a movie dead. Or perhaps there was inadequate projection, which can kill a movie dead.

Oh. Laff riot. I should mention laff riot. In younger years, I would sit in an auditorium and watch a single movie two or three times over, matinée and evening performances, and I noticed that each audience reacted entirely differently. One example that I remember vividly is Humphrey Bogart in The Big Sleep. Wonderful movie. The matinée audience accepted it as a drama, but they did chuckle mildly two or three times at some of the witty dialogue. The nighttime audience laughed loudly almost from beginning to end, sometimes so raucously that they completely drowned out the best lines. That was not a one-off experience. That was not an unusual experience. That was typical. Different audiences react differently. One audience accepted Dr. Strangelove as a gripping drama. Another audience laughed joyously throughout. Wonderful movie that second time. There is a group dynamic, and each person in the auditorium feeds and feeds off of every other person in the auditorium.

We also need to take into account the musical accompaniment. A sensitive score that is attendant upon the needs of the narrative will bring the movie to life. An inappropriate score that imposes an interpretation upon the film or that contradicts the narrative will kill the movie dead. An inattentive score by a tired or lazy or demoralized musician will render the film unwatchable. Good accompaniment allows for laughter. Mediocre accompaniment might allow for a few chuckles, but nothing more. Poor accompaniment will leave the audience feeling miserable. Audiences will not attribute the entertainment quality, or lack thereof, to the musicians. They will attribute it to the film alone. Live accompaniment is one of the grand ingredients that makes silent cinema a unique delight, but it is a dangerous weapon when placed into the wrong hands.

In my personal opinion, The General is beyond any measure the funniest of all of Buster’s movies. Nothing else he did is as humorous or as brilliant. Of course, now that I’ve seen it probably a hundred times, I no longer laugh, but oh those first few times, it brought on convulsions. Sometimes it works that way for a whole audience. Other audiences watch The General and react with mild amusement. Yet other audiences don’t react at all. Group dynamic. Also, different people find different things funny. Some people find the Three Stooges funny. I don’t. Not at all. Some people find The Flintstones funny. I don’t. Not at all. Some people find Abbott & Costello funny. I find them repulsive. Some people don’t find From Soup to Nuts funny. Those are the people who can never be my friends. Because The General is played entirely straight, with no clowning at all, and because it is never played for laughs, it’s the funniest darned thing I’ve ever seen. The comedy derives from irony, from reaction, from the absurdism immanent in reality. Nothing can outdo it.

(Click here to continue)